Pound for Pound Dilemma: Who’s really #1? Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[dumber79]

currently, manny. but come summer, PBF. I really hope PBF steps in with one of the top 147 o.e cotto, SSM and beats them. he's no need to fight manny ,as manny will be rooting round for his teeth in the MGM grand after RH has brushed him aside.

In worse case, manny beats hatton, manny steps in with PBF and PBF shows him up.

[Ishy Aytan]

There really is no dilemma for me, Pacquiao is pound for pound number 1.

Precisely, Floyd has'nt fought in more than 12 months. The only way he gets his p4p no1 status back is by beating Pacquaio.

[patpat0928]

as of now pacquiao, but if pbf beats marquez decisively, short of domination, he regains P4P no. 1 status. anyway, dominating jmm is quite difficult so i dont believe floyd will regain his former status immediately.

the fastest way to become no. 1 is to beat the current no. 1, which is manny pacquiao.

[-EX-]

Floyd Joy Mayweather Sr = P4P #1

[120]

doesn't matter.

when quintana beat williams and williams beat marg and marg beat cotto and cotto beat shane......it showed that floyd was the best at 147.

of course, then williams went and won in 154 and 160 so this clearly shows that mayweather is also the best in 154 and 160. so Floyd is the best from 106(because at one point in his life he weighted it) up to 160 so far. Actually since trinidad and dlh fought at 168 also this means that Mayweather is also the best at 168. #p# of all time

[Papa Ace]

PBF beats Marquez he regains No. 1 P4P status? He didnt even beat a guy his own size and avoided guys on his weight. Wow.

[Left Hook Tua]

of course, then williams went and won in 154 and 160 so this clearly shows that mayweather is also the best in 154 and 160. so Floyd is the best from 106(because at one point in his life he weighted it) up to 160 so far. Actually since trinidad and dlh fought at 168 also this means that Mayweather is also the best at 168. #p# of all time

i like how you think!

[mines a pasty]

If FM was still active (taking into account you couldnt second guess the last 18 months) i'd still pick Manny. I just think he's more fearless than Floyd, and at the end of the day, holds a better CV.

[Left Hook Tua]

If FM was still active (taking into account you couldnt second guess the last 18 months) i'd still pick Manny. I just think he's more fearless than Floyd, and at the end of the day, holds a better CV.

floyd's resume pwns manny's!

how much ppv can manny draw?

[Doop]

doesn't matter.

when quintana beat williams and williams beat marg and marg beat cotto and cotto beat shane......it showed that floyd was the best at 147.

Your vote/opinion is invalid as you'd probably suck on Floyds wang if you ever had the chance.

Manny Pacquiao #1