What if pacquiao-hatton was earlier?

[dibzvincent143]

Both of the fighters have improved their boxing skills no doubt.
BUT what if the situation goes like this:

Right after Manny Pacquiao beated JMM via split.
He immediately climb at 140 instead of 135 and foght Ricky hatton
who was defeated by Floyd Mayweather that time.

Considering their peformances at:
Pacquiao-Diaz and Hatton-Laczano.

and also cosidering their trainers at that time.

who would've won?

for me.I think its manny,manny was at 146 when he slaughtered Diaz.
Hatton had a bad performance against Laczano.

what do you think guys?

[J.B.moneY.]

this is what i;ve been trying to tell people is before...pac-oscar....60% thought hatton would beat pac.....now convetional wisdom has been throw out......sure manny is a special fighter.....

but usually coventional wisdom is right 2/3 of the time....

and conventional wisdom suggest hatton wins by KO!

[Burner]

this is what i;ve been trying to tell people is before...pac-oscar....60% thought hatton would beat pac.....now convetional wisdom has been throw out......sure manny is a special fighter.....

but usually coventional wisdom is right 2/3 of the time....

and conventional wisdom suggest hatton wins by KO!

I remeber Hatton vs. Pav threads before Diaz and ODH...and Pac was given NO CHANCE AT ALL.

[THe TRiNiTY]

If 'if' was a fifth, we'd all be drunk.

I'd have still picked Pacquiao to beat Hatton when he beat David Diaz. Hatton struggled with Juan Lazcano.

[nujabes77]

this is what i;ve been trying to tell people is before...pac-oscar....60% thought hatton would beat pac.....now convetional wisdom has been throw out......sure manny is a special fighter.....

but usually coventional wisdom is right 2/3 of the time....

and conventional wisdom suggest hatton wins by KO!

he matured as a boxer, and in peak form right now