If Pac beats them all ...

[Thwf]

where do u think MP should be thwf sir?

I think easily ATG top 5. But if he adds a SWW alpha belt and be the only boxer to earn 7 alpha titles/weight class in history, and possibly 5 lineal titles in history, he easily takes top 3 in my opinion.

This is actually no joke cuz if he gets past Hatton, his next fights are 100% sure to be against Cotto and PBF. This is a very near possibility.

[TintaBoricua]

Depends on how he beats them. But regardless, beating them alone (and assuming Cotto is still the same, as is Mayweather) would put Pacquiao in...i dunno. I'm pretty sure I'd be exagerrating by saying top five, but I'm certain most will say top 10...at the very least.

[miron_lang]

Fought and Kayoed a Regional champion at 17

Fought and kayoed a Linear WORLD champion at 19 ( 112 )

Kayoed an IBF WORLD Champion ( Ranked #2 @122 )

Kayoed a Legendary Linear Featherweight Champion

Beaten Juan Manuel Marquez for the WBC and Linear Championship @130

Won an alphabet at Lightweight ( WBC ) for a tuneup

Convincingly Stopped Legends Erik Morales ( 2X ) and Oscar Dela Hoya ( 147 )

-----


Adding

HaTTOn 1 loss
Mayweather Undefeated
Cotto 1 loss

WOULD make PAC TOP 5 IMO.... Anything lower than TOP 10 is ridiculous.

[koboy]

Fought and Kayoed a Regional champion at 17

Fought and kayoed a Linear WORLD champion at 19 ( 112 )

Kayoed an IBF WORLD Champion ( Ranked #2 @122 )

Kayoed a Legendary Linear Featherweight Champion

Beaten Juan Manuel Marquez for the WBC and Linear Championship @130

Won an alphabet at Lightweight ( WBC ) for a tuneup

Convincingly Stopped Legends Erik Morales ( 2X ) and Oscar Dela Hoya ( 147 )

-----


Adding

HaTTOn 1 loss
Mayweather Undefeated
Cotto 1 loss

WOULD make PAC TOP 5 IMO.... Anything lower than TOP 10 is ridiculous.

Let's say Pac does beat all of these guys, who is your top 5 ATG then?

[shadeyfizzle]

I still stand by top 50. Nowadays, they just don't fight as much as they use to. 2 fights a year vs 5 or 6 tough fights per year is the diffence between past greats and current greats.

Top 100 is just too low.

If he beats them convincingly, KOs all of 'em, probably Top 25 - 30.

I love Manny and I hope he wins all of them and prove me wrong, but to compare them to the top 30-40 ATGs, he just might not measure up.

1st of all. Who's to say the past greats fought 5-6 TOUGH fights per year every year?? They fought on a more consistent basis to stay sharp but there is no denying that most of those were local fighters. What woul be equivalent to today's sparring partners. I'm not gonna say that these past greats padded their records....but it is a byproduct of these fights that were not supposed to be anything more than to keep these past greats' senses and reflexes sharp.

2nd of all...Just take a look at where Manny Pacquiao would stand in this hypothetical situation if he beat all 3 guys.

He would have for sure 4 lineal titles, perhaps 5. (Only fighter in history to ever do so)

He would have won titles in his 7th weight division (Most ever in history. Jumping a total of 10 weight divisions from where he started his career)

On top of that beating PBF proves Manny Pacquiao without a shadow of a doubt the greatest fighter of his generation regardless of weight class.


All that and to keep Manny Pacquiao out of the top 10 would be a crime against the sport. I would have him in the top 3 all time right in between Armstrong and Ali.

[Hook]

Top ten,,,,,,,,,,

[ACHlLLES]

koboy is the worst poster on this forum, he admitted to me he is flawless in private message.

[koboy]

koboy is the worst poster on this forum, he admitted to me he is flawless in private message.

You mean this private message:

Re: HOW DO U LIKE RED K BACK FLAWLESS
Quote:
Originally Posted by koboySucksIt
U ****TY POSTER, NO ONES LIKES UR RACIST ASS FLAWLESS, LEAVE BOXINGSCENE

This proves my point of you just going off without proof to satisfy your angry ass. First, you call me Malcolm and then Flawless. I wonder how many people who have debunked your posts who you've called these ****** names. I've been here since 04 you ****ing noob and I have never had an alt and have just recently posted because I was actually getting tired of reading from posters like yourwho just ****ing yap without any facts or proof or type in CAPS like a 5 year trying to intimidate other posters. Internet tough guy. If anyone should leave, it is you.

I ask you again, where is your proof that I am racist? Because I disagreed with you. Where is your proof that I am either Malcolm or Flawless? None. You're just assuming because I posted something that disagreed with your pathetic post. Why don't you pull all my post and prove that I am a racist or Malcolm or Flawless. You can't because all you ****ing do is yap, yap, yap. You are a sad little boy. I can't believe you even had the time to change your name and you think this will insult me? Hello, this name doesn't mean **** to me, it's just my boxingscene name since I joined in '04. I hope I am eating away at you because you are just too easy.

[ACHlLLES]

Re: So what if I'm flawless, ****ing ****** honkey
Quote:
Originally Posted by koboy

I don't care what people think about me on here, unlike you losers I have a life.






That is what koboy sent me.

[miron_lang]

Let's say Pac does beat all of these guys, who is your top 5 ATG then?

Robinson
Ali
Armstrong
PAC
Joe Louis


Who is your TOP 5 if PAC beats those 3?