Mayweather vs. Pacquiao All Time Status

[sandyvahra]

5 division in a 9 years undefeated..
most of pacman's resume were past prime fighters or not clear cut victories.

not to hate either

in my opinon, pac's best victories are against barrera the 1st fight, and the marquez fights.. and i along with many others thought marquez won both those fights against pacman.. how does pac get credit for beating zombie de la hoya and pbf doesnt when they were at a higher weight and pbf had to concede to everything? its hatred.. pac gets credit for beating a faded morales and barerra (2nd fight) and has life and death matches with marquez, beats a zombie, and a contender in diaz and all the sudden he shoots pass mayweather for atg great rankings?? nah sorry i cant go with that

Pacquiao definatly. Based off pretty much what everyone else has brought up. Although I'd still have to compare Pacquiao's W and Floyd's W. If Pacquiao wins a close decision it would bring him down a bit in comparison than if he got the KO. It would still be impressive and I'd put Pacquiao ahead but not by as much.

co-sign, a lot will factor on how he wins the fight. A close points win or a KO change the complexion on how much higher it would put him.

[ILLuminato]

Even if Pacquiao loses closely to Hatton I have him ranked higher.... Pacquiao started at 106 I mean come on...

The *****'s got owned in htis poll

[sandyvahra]

[QUOTE=The *****'s got owned in htis poll[/QUOTE]

LOL. The arguments for Manny are stronger. You call a spade a spade.

[chinoy]

I voted for the boxer who started his Pro career at FLYWEIGHT

[Rich Loc]

Even if Pacquiao loses closely to Hatton I have him ranked higher.... Pacquiao started at 106 I mean come on...

The *****'s got owned in htis poll

How old was Pacman when he weighed 106, he was 16
Floyd at 16 was also fighting at 106

[Rich Loc]

Floyd without a doubt
He lost to a past it Morales. Then beat the weight drained version TWICE
He clearly lost to JMM TWICE
Beating weight drained Oscar
MAB was a great win

[chinoy]

Floyd at 16 was also fighting at 106

How sure are you Mayweather was 106 lbs when he was 16 y/o??????? can you post a link to this.....

I havent seen a 16 y/o black man who weighs 106 lbs

[Rich Loc]

How sure are you Mayweather was 106 lbs when he was 16 y/o??????? can you post a link to this.....

I havent seen a 16 y/o black man who weighs 106 lbs

Mayweather won national Golden Gloves championships in 1993 (at 106 lb)
Light Flyweight Champion

http://www.boxrec.com/media/index.php?title=Human:352

[Tha_Greatest]

So Pacquiao is better than Mayweather because he has a "better" resume?

and you know this

[GoAltYourFace]

Good thing that has nothing to do with the thread topic.

hahaha u just made my day