If Floyd wants to be considered great...

[iron lung]

What challenges did he avoid???
He offered Mosley fight numerous times. Cotto never called his name OUT EVER. Williams nor Pacman were mentioned with Floyd few years ago. Margarito did call him out, but a win over him would do nothing more

Mosley and Cotto both ducked Mayweather and turned him down. There's documented proof just google it there's a quote from Bob Arum who says "Miguel Cotto needs another 12 months before he is ready for Mayweather" when Mayweather called him out a year or two ago.

[FreshPrince]

And how many questionable decisions has Oscar gotten because of his Golden Boy status.
Floyd should have gotten a UD
Whitaker fight
Strum Fight
Ike Fight

And going on to get smashed by Pac(But was weight drained)

He beat Quartey and Whitaker, AND Trinidad. Floyd did earn a UD imo, and Sturm was robbed.

[Rich Loc]

He beat Quartey and Whitaker, AND Trinidad. Floyd did earn a UD imo, and Sturm was robbed.

He lost to Ike and Pernell easily. Pernell fight more clearly. Who scores a round just because of a late flurry?

[Roger Mellie]

And how many questionable decisions has Oscar gotten because of his Golden Boy status.
Floyd should have gotten a UD
Whitaker fight
Strum Fight
Ike Fight

And going on to get smashed by Pac(But was weight drained)

thats irrelevant.Oscar fought everyone.There were no challenges left for him,and no question marks.Floyd has enormous questions left unanswered.

[cuzfozzy]

I put mayweather above oscar because they fought and mayweather beat him.
thats the only way you can ever judge them ... in the ring ...
oscar fought more opponents to his credit but he lost alot of those

[Rich Loc]

thats irrelevant.Oscar fought everyone.There were no challenges left for him,and no question marks.Floyd has enormous questions left unanswered.

Oscar has left more questions than answers. Ike Strum Pernell fights are all questionable. He never fought Winky Forrest. He choose Pacman over Margarito

[FreshPrince]

And how many questionable decisions has Oscar gotten because of his Golden Boy status.
Floyd should have gotten a UD
Whitaker fight
Strum Fight
Ike Fight

And going on to get smashed by Pac(But was weight drained)

What about the Castillo fight? That changed his whole career. It should have been his first loss and then he wouldn't be cherry picking opponents the rest of his career to keep his undefeated record. Also the knock down that wasn't called in the Judah fight changed the whole fight. Zab was winning rounds, and a 10-8 round would have given him confidence and kept him from imploding later on in the fight.

[Roger Mellie]

Oscar has left more questions than answers. Ike Strum Pernell fights are all questionable. He never fought Winky Forrest. He choose Pacman over Margarito

Face it,if mr.boatbuyer is as great as he says he is,then why is he not making these fights?

[Rich Loc]

What about the Castillo fight? That changed his whole career. It should have been his first loss and then he wouldn't be cherry picking opponents the rest of his career to keep his undefeated record. Also the knock down that wasn't called in the Judah fight changed the whole fight. Zab was winning rounds, and a 10-8 round would have given him confidence and kept him from imploding later on in the fight.

What about the Castillo fight?? That was one close fight. He rematched his immediately. Did Oscar rematch Ike Strum Pernell???

Judah would still have lost to PBF even if the knock down was given.

Face it,if mr.boatbuyer is as great as he says he is,then why is he not making these fights?

Greatness is determined by winning a fight in dramatic fashion leaving no questions

Ike
Pernell
Strum
Tito


All left questions

[FreshPrince]

What about the Castillo fight?? That was one close fight. He rematched his immediately. Did Oscar rematch Ike Strum Pernell???

It wasn't even that close of a fight. He clearly lost by a few rounds. Even clearly winning the rematch, that loss should have changed his entire career and not prohibit him from taking chances to preserve his record.