Better Resume: Oscar or Evander???

[RightCross94]

Discuss.......

[FreshPrince]

The Real Deal. Best resume this side of Ali. Oscar's is great too.

[Jim Jeffries]

Resume, as in counting losses as well, or just wins?

[RightCross94]

Resume, as in counting losses as well, or just wins?

as in comp fought plus quality of their key wins

[Left Hook Tua]

oscar.

trinidad , chavez , whitaker , mayweather , pacquiao , hopkins , mosley , quartey , vargas , ruelas , genaro , john john , gatti , paez......

if the guy fought at 130-160 the last 15 years......oscar has fought them.

[Left Hook Tua]

as in comp fought plus quality of their key wins

aside from the pacquiao loss , you can count all of oscar's losses as a plus to his resume.

i mean it's arguable that he beat tito and mosley , he was competitive with floyd despite being old and past prime and the hopkins ko was excusable seeing as bernard was a huge middleweight.

[713832281]

holyfield, imo cuz he won alot of his big fights. in his day heavyweight division was stacked.

[Pullcounter]

dlh has the better resume but holyfield is 10x a better fighter than dlh

[Left Hook Tua]

holyfield, imo cuz he won alot of his big fights. in his day heavyweight division was stacked.

oscar fought better competition than holyfield.

holyfield's resume is way overblown. it's a great resume but it's not better than oscar's.

[lance_uppercut]

They both have great resumes despite forgiving whatever big name fights they may have one or lost but to me holyfield edges it slightly due to his trilogy with bowe and a few other key fights like tyson 2x, foreman, moorer, etc