James Toney's win over Evander Holyfield is underrated.

[cuzfozzy]

david haye calls out the klitschkos and he gets a fight
despite having almost zero experience at heavyweight

toney does the same for 2 years longer but there's no response

[Silencers]

Holyfield was way past his best, even back then.

[Spray_resistant]

david haye calls out the klitschkos and he gets a fight
despite having almost zero experience at heavyweight

toney does the same for 2 years longer but there's no response

I mean can you blame them after Toney's masterful performances against Sam Peter, and more recently Oquendo.

[Jim Jeffries]

I mean can you blame them after Toney's masterful performances against Sam Peter, and more recently Oquendo.

I think Toney won the first Peter fight.

[Spray_resistant]

I think Toney won the first Peter fight.

In an impressive manner?

[Jim Jeffries]

In an impressive manner?

Impressive enough considering the size differential and Peter's status at the time. No way Peter won that fight.

[Bea5T]

Again that wasnt a prime Evander, how do you rate Berbick's win over Ali?

evander still was decent


not too mention everyone knows evander should have valuevs belt right now

[Chunk..]

He completely schooled him and beat him at his own game.

Holyfield was shot by the time Toney got to him.

[RiZО]

Holyfield was shot by the time Toney got to him.

The odds were all againts Toney at the time and he knocked Holyfield out.

[Spray_resistant]

Impressive enough considering the size differential and Peter's status at the time. No way Peter won that fight.

I had Toney winning that one too but by a sight margin, many of the rounds were close so it wouldn't be out of the question if someone had Peter winning.