Who beat the better competition Pacquiao or Hatton

[baracuda]

barrera and morales was 29 when he first fought them.

marquez was 30 the first time they fought.

oscar was the same age as kostya.

very good point!

[street bully]

Ron Lyle without a doubt.

On a side note, Pacquaio has the better resume by far.

[syphillis]

we just need our aging defense to hold it together 1 or 2 more years if not reload.

cutler , forte , hester , olsen......

does anyone have a better young qb/rd/wr/te combo than that? i don't think so........

I agree with the defense. Urlacher seems to be losing his speed a bit and is showing wear and tear. Briggs and other linebackers should be able hold on their own. The secondary looks small as usual. By the way, did you know Cutler is diabetic?

[baracuda]

LOL, aging MAB. MAB was 29 i believed when he lost to Pac in the first fight.

And Tzyu was 34-35 years old when he lost to Hatton.

true!mab was born in 1974 ;he fought manny in 2003,he was 29 and so as erik!jmm fought him the first time at around that age too!

[baracuda]

no way those dwarf bums that pac fought are better then hatton's bums...i'll take the pepsi challenge on that one

ask michael moorer about ricky hatton.he said:hatton is an overrated fighter,he's never really fought anybody worthy and won!look it up in you tube!not the exact words but close

[Ido]

Why bother asking the question? Pac-Man has victories over future hall of famers. Eric Morales, Marco Antonio Barrera, and Juan Manuel Marquez are vary respectable opponents.

[Pullcounter]

ask michael moorer about ricky hatton.he said:hatton is an overrated fighter,he's never really fought anybody worthy and won!look it up in you tube!not the exact words but close

i wouldn't say he's overrated. hatton is what he is; but what he is not is an ATG

[hammerhiem]

i wouldn't say he's overrated. hatton is what he is; but what he is not is an ATG

Exactly, he's a very good but not great Jr WW who will be top 10 all time in his own country, but short of the ATG lists on both ability and resume.

Doesn't mean he's crap and/or not beaten anyone.

He has 8 solid names on his resume @world level and will probably retire with 12-13 depending on how many more fights he has.

Most fighters would be more than happy with that.

[fcastro1]

Pacmans ressume is quite alot better, but it's ashame certain people are downplaying Hatton's wins over Castillo Tyzu and acting like Pacman fought the best versions of everyone he faced.

castillo was shot, tszyu was inactive but a good win. pac faced barrera when he was on his best run, morales was slightly past it and marquez was prime when he fought him.

[BritishFightFan]

This was an an impressive victory against an ATG in Jose Luis Castillo.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6UeYWanxhfs

Not sure the Malignaggi victory is as great, though.

As for Barrera, when he fought Pacquiao he was sadly a shell of his former self as he peaked extremely early.