How Would Of Joe Calzaghe done against these four fighters?

**The Gunner** · 04-05-2009, 03:52 PM

He doesn't lose he'd have beat them all

**boxasmash** · 04-05-2009, 03:56 PM

wins them all

nunn being the hardest fight of them.

**winac** · 04-05-2009, 04:05 PM

He'd beat them

**TheGreatA** · 04-05-2009, 04:12 PM

Calzaghe beats McClellan as long as he doesn't get caught (which is possible). The G-Man was untested in the later rounds (or I'd say proven to be vulnerable).

Nunn presents the most trouble for Calzaghe if in his 160 form. He had declined by the time he fought at 168.

Barkley was no Jeff Lacy. He could trouble Calzaghe like Bika did if the fight gets rough but Calzaghe at his best could also put on a boxing clinic due to Barkley's one dimensional style and lack of defense.

Tony Ayala was a light middleweight and looked a little soft even at that weight. He was untested as a boxer and would likely be bloated at 168 where he doesn't belong. Calzaghe should handle him quite easily, in my opinion.

**cotto16** · 04-05-2009, 04:19 PM

Originally posted by TheManchine

Calzaghe beats McClellan as long as he doesn't get caught (which is possible). The G-Man was untested in the later rounds (or I'd say proven to be vulnerable).

Nunn presents the most trouble for Calzaghe if in his 160 form. He had declined by the time he fought at 168.

Barkley was no Jeff Lacy. He could trouble Calzaghe like Bika did if the fight gets rough but Calzaghe at his best could also put on a boxing clinic due to Barkley's one dimensional style and lack of defense.

Tony Ayala was a light middleweight and looked a little soft even at that weight. He was untested as a boxer and would likely be bloated at 168 where he doesn't belong. Calzaghe should handle him quite easily, in my opinion.

Alot of Ayala's fight's were at middle and some at 168 aswell, as Ayala wasn't soft he was a fixed set built.

**CaRnAgEViOLaToR** · 04-05-2009, 04:22 PM

sorry cant see joe stopping nunn. i think thats a fight that wouldve been close but nunn at his best could beat joe.

mcclellan wouldve had a good chance to beat him as well.

**daggum** · 04-05-2009, 04:22 PM

Originally posted by cotto16

Gerald McClellan at 168. I think g man takes this one

Michael Nunn at 168. Joe maybe late stoppage

Iran Bakley at 168. ?

Tony Ayala at 168 ?

look up the nunn vs kalambay fight.
calzaghe would be kalambay btw.

**Ryn0** · 04-05-2009, 04:26 PM

IMO the hardest fight there is the G-man. He beats everyone else Ayala and Barkley comfortably maybe even TKO's barkley off accumulation (Barkelys defensive holes) and Nunn by Close decision.

Gerald IMO if he lands a big one he could get Joe outta there otherwise Calzaghe takes advantage of McCllelans late round fading to win a UD

**NakiFan** · 04-05-2009, 04:28 PM

Wins them all

How Would Of Joe Calzaghe done against these four fighters?