Kelly Pavlik vs David Tua who has the better wins?

[ACHlLLES]

Kelly Pavlik: Taylor, Miranda, McKart, Zuniga

David Tua: Rahman, Ruiz, Moorer


I think its Pavlik, tua has those kind of wins that make him sound like he is a jeff lacy impersonator by getting schooled by lennox lewis for 12 rounds. You know the stepping stone of the division for the elite fighters. Pavlik beat taylor, the guy who has wins over hopkins and a draw with wright.

[PrettyBoyRoy 88]

I chose Pavlik because he's younger and is already, pretty much, on par with Tua's resume.

[Left Hook Tua]

tua beat

hasim rahman
oleg maskaev
fres oquendo
john ruiz
michael moorer
danell nicholson
obed sullivan
david izon

pavlik beat

jermain taylor
gary lockett

[ACHlLLES]

Pavlik beat:

Taylor twice
Miranda
Zuniga
Zertuche
McKart

[Komander]

Gary Lockett alone is far better than any oppponent Tua has ever stepped in the ring with.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

vinny paziensa..........

[Left Hook Tua]

Gary Lockett alone is far better than any oppponent Tua has ever stepped in the ring with.

gary lockett >>>>> lennox lewis

[S.G.]

it's essentially, is Taylor (x2) and Miranda better than Moorer, Ruiz, Rahman and Maskaev?

not a bad comparison but Tua takes it. Pavlik should overtake him by the end of his career

[ACHlLLES]

it's essentially, is Taylor (x2) and Miranda better than Moorer, Ruiz, Rahman and Maskaev?

not a bad comparison but Tua takes it. Pavlik should overtake him by the end of his career

He definitely will if their are big enough names that want to fight him. I don't think he should fight AA though. I think AA is stylistically all wrong for Pavlik. People could look down on Pavlik if he loses to AA even though AA is a tough fighter himself.

[S.G.]

He definitely will if their are big enough names that want to fight him. I don't think he should fight AA though. I think AA is stylistically all wrong for Pavlik. People could look down on Pavlik if he loses to AA even though AA is a tough fighter himself.

i think he could easily outpoint Abraham, and that'll be a real nice scalp on his resume

provided he doesn't lose again before he's reestablished himself, he should have a good career ahead of him