Yahoo's best ever in each division.

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • KingTito
    Undisputed Champion
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Mar 2006
    • 9391
    • 234
    • 350
    • 22,960

    #1

    Yahoo's best ever in each division.

    I disagree with some of it.

    Mailbag: Best of the original eight
    By Kevin Iole, Yahoo! Sports
    Mar 24, 12:20 pm EDT

    I watched a couple of DVDs of the late Salvador Sanchez on Saturday, before I saw the live shows on television featuring Vitali Klitschko’s knockout of Juan Carlos Gomez and Roy Jones’ victory over Omar Sheika.

    Sanchez was a wonderful fighter whose life was tragically cut short in 1982 in an auto accident. He was 44-1-1 and one of the great featherweights who ever lived.

    That got me thinking of the best fighters in each of the original eight weight classes. I’m picking my choices in each class based on when they were at their best. Feel free to disagree.

    • Heavyweight: 1, Joe Louis; 2, Larry Holmes; 3, Muhammad Ali.

    • Light heavyweight: 1, Archie Moore; 2, Ezzard Charles; 3, Billy Conn.

    • Middleweight: 1, Harry Greb; 2, Marvelous Marvin Hagler; 3, Stanley Ketchel.

    • Welterweight: 1, Sugar Ray Robinson; 2, Sugar Ray Leonard; 3, Jose Napoles.

    • Lightweight: 1, Benny Leonard; 2, Roberto Duran; 3, Barney Ross.

    • Featherweight: 1, Henry Armstrong; 2, Willie Pep; 3, Sandy Saddler.

    • Bantamweight: 1, Eder Jofre; 2, Ruben Olivares; 3, Carlos Zarate.

    • Flyweight: 1, Jimmy Wilde; 2, Miguel Cantu; 3, Pancho Villa.
  • THE REED
    Sixty Forty
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Apr 2007
    • 43489
    • 1,992
    • 1,483
    • 690,068,075

    #2
    Larry Holmes #2 best HW ever??????

    Comment

    • savorduhflavor
      Undisputed Champion
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Oct 2008
      • 8194
      • 288
      • 59
      • 14,875

      #3
      Originally posted by reedickyaluss
      Larry Holmes #2 best HW ever??????
      What I was gonna say. **** leaped off the page at me. That's some blasphemy right there.

      Comment

      • IwatchBoxing
        Banned
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • Dec 2004
        • 10527
        • 235
        • 403
        • 11,555

        #4
        Great list !!

        Comment

        • THE REED
          Sixty Forty
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Apr 2007
          • 43489
          • 1,992
          • 1,483
          • 690,068,075

          #5
          Originally posted by savorduhflavor
          What I was gonna say. **** leaped off the page at me. That's some blasphemy right there.
          lmao @ Larry Holmes having a better resume then Ali.... WTF

          Comment

          • TheGreatA
            Undisputed Champion
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Dec 2007
            • 14143
            • 633
            • 271
            • 21,863

            #6
            Originally posted by KingTito
            I disagree with some of it.

            Mailbag: Best of the original eight
            By Kevin Iole, Yahoo! Sports
            Mar 24, 12:20 pm EDT

            I watched a couple of DVDs of the late Salvador Sanchez on Saturday, before I saw the live shows on television featuring Vitali Klitschko’s knockout of Juan Carlos Gomez and Roy Jones’ victory over Omar Sheika.

            Sanchez was a wonderful fighter whose life was tragically cut short in 1982 in an auto accident. He was 44-1-1 and one of the great featherweights who ever lived.

            That got me thinking of the best fighters in each of the original eight weight classes. I’m picking my choices in each class based on when they were at their best. Feel free to disagree.

            • Heavyweight: 1, Joe Louis; 2, Larry Holmes; 3, Muhammad Ali.

            • Light heavyweight: 1, Archie Moore; 2, Ezzard Charles; 3, Billy Conn.

            • Middleweight: 1, Harry Greb; 2, Marvelous Marvin Hagler; 3, Stanley Ketchel.

            • Welterweight: 1, Sugar Ray Robinson; 2, Sugar Ray Leonard; 3, Jose Napoles.

            • Lightweight: 1, Benny Leonard; 2, Roberto Duran; 3, Barney Ross.

            • Featherweight: 1, Henry Armstrong; 2, Willie Pep; 3, Sandy Saddler.

            • Bantamweight: 1, Eder Jofre; 2, Ruben Olivares; 3, Carlos Zarate.

            • Flyweight: 1, Jimmy Wilde; 2, Miguel Cantu; 3, Pancho Villa.
            I would have Ali #1 or #2, Monzon in the top 3 instead of Ketchel, Pep and Saddler ahead of Armstrong at FW. There are other questionable picks as well but it's his opinion.

            Comment

            • Fulcrum29
              Banned
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Aug 2008
              • 4171
              • 171
              • 44
              • 4,430

              #7
              Originally posted by savorduhflavor
              What I was gonna say. **** leaped off the page at me. That's some blasphemy right there.
              not necessarily. many people place holmes over ali.

              Comment

              • THE REED
                Sixty Forty
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Apr 2007
                • 43489
                • 1,992
                • 1,483
                • 690,068,075

                #8
                Originally posted by IwatchBoxing
                Great list !!
                I dont agree with Holmes... he has some good wins like

                Shavers
                Norton
                Berbick
                Spinks....
                Mercer
                Cooney
                I dont count his win over Ali... no way.

                But I mean ALI?

                Liston
                Frazier
                Foreman
                Spinks
                Shavers
                Norton
                Patterson
                Quarry
                Archie Moore - Which I wont really count either

                Comment

                • -Antonio-
                  -Antonio-
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Jun 2005
                  • 24259
                  • 629
                  • 163
                  • 38,153

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Fulcrum29
                  not necessarily. many people place holmes over ali.
                  Many ******ed people. Ali's resume is too good for Holmes to even have a case.

                  Comment

                  • IwatchBoxing
                    Banned
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Dec 2004
                    • 10527
                    • 235
                    • 403
                    • 11,555

                    #10
                    Originally posted by reedickyaluss
                    I dont agree with Holmes... he has some good wins like

                    Shavers
                    Norton
                    Berbick
                    Spinks....
                    Mercer
                    Cooney
                    I dont count his win over Ali... no way.

                    But I mean ALI?

                    Liston
                    Frazier
                    Foreman
                    Spinks
                    Shavers
                    Norton
                    Patterson
                    Quarry
                    Archie Moore - Which I wont really count either
                    Some flops but I've seen worse.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP