If Taylor beats Froch p4p top 10?

[Roger Yomama]

But those 2 loses were close, and Froch is an undefeated champ.
Also, hatton did nothing but is in the P4P, and who the *** is P williams, and what has he done? beat margarita??
Dawson nearly lost to an old man, or should i say lost to an old man?

I think some of you guys underestimate a win over Froch

Those 3 words alone are enough to discredit your post as nonsense.

[VirusTI]

so would you put Dawson of hatton ahead of Taylor if he beats froch?

[TheManchine]

But those 2 loses were close, and Froch is an undefeated champ.
Also, hatton did nothing but is in the P4P, and who the *** is P williams, and what has he done? beat margarita??
Dawson nearly lost to an old man, or should i say lost to an old man?

I think some of you guys underestimate a win over Froch

Pavlik knocked him out cold , what's close about that?

[VirusTI]

ok Roger yomama, tell me why losing lopsided fight to floyd and walking down a dude who hits lighter than Calz shouls get you into p4p 10?

[$partacus]

If Taylor beats Froch he might get in the top 20 but not 10.

[roundingace]

ok Roger yomama, tell me why losing lopsided fight to floyd and walking down a dude who hits lighter than Calz shouls get you into p4p 10?

Cause he's been undefeated at 140lbs for 10 years. That alone, puts him ahead of JT.

[VirusTI]

Being undefeated at 140 with wins over a way past his prime Kostya, vs being unified Middle weight champ and beating a close to prime Hopkins and wright hmmm....

[roundingace]

Being undefeated at 140 with wins over a way past his prime Kostya, vs being unified Middle weight champ and beating a close to prime Hopkins and wright hmmm....

Ricky beat down his opponents and yes, even Kostya no matter how much credit you DON'T wanna give him for that win when, literally, NOBODY gave him a chance in that fight. You can argue Taylor lost all 3 of those fights with Hop and Winky especially, so stop. The man has had a great career so far, but his losses have taken him back a step, nothing wrong with that and I see him regaining his stature in the near future starting with Froch. Just not top 10 P4P status.

[Roger Yomama]

ok Roger yomama, tell me why losing lopsided fight to floyd and walking down a dude who hits lighter than Calz shouls get you into p4p 10?

At no point did I say Hatton is a p4p top 10 fighter. The point I was making is that you said Hatton has done nothing, when it's blatantly obvious to anyone that he has achieved more than enough already to be considered as having had an excellent career.

Hatton has one defeat on his record. To the man who will go down as the best fighter of his generation!! He has been the #1 guy at 140 for around 5 years now, was prepared to travel to America to make his name and get the big fights (unlike Calzaghe) and has consistently done good business at the box office.

Taylor was the man at 160 for 18 months, couldn't fill an elevator and got blasted out by Pavlik who is a one dimensional slugger.

[NakiFan]

No, I don't think so, as much as Froch wont be if he beats Taylor.