Originally posted by Testdead
View Post
This is the way I see the matchup:
If I had my life on the line I am picking Calzaghe every time. He is the most consistent, predictable fighter. You know he is coming in focused and in shape every single time.
The same cannot be said for Toney. However, a prime, in shape and focused Toney is a scary thing, especially at 168 which was definately his best weight. The Toney that fought Iran Barkley would have given anyone who ever fought at 168 everything they could handle. I think that Toney edges Joe, but it is very close.
But yeah, if they did ever actually fight I would have picked Joe for the reasons stated above.
Comment