Who has the better (WINS) on their resume.

[Dynamite Kid]

Calzaghe has Lacy, Kessler, jones jr, eubank, hopkins

Difficult to say. Holmes had about as much left as Jones. No Holmes had a lot more left than Jones actually.

Lacy is no better than Trevor Berbick.

Hopkins i dont consider a win for Calzaghe, because imo he did not win the fight.


Eubank/Kessler

As Machine said

Berbick (WBC)
Tucker (IBF)
Bonecrusher (WBA).
Spinks (the ring)

[Reggie Miller]

Tyson has spinks, holmes... And thats all I can think of right now

Calzaghe has Lacy, Kessler, jones jr, eubank, hopkins

Tyson has Spinks (who beat holmes TWICE), Holmes (who destroyed ALI), Berbick (who also destroyed ali), Bruno (TWICE), Ruddock (TWICE), Pinklon Thomas.

Tyson's resume> Calzaghe's

[AntDawg]

Gonna have to go with Tyson.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

beating hopkins>>>>tyson resume

unifying the HW division in 19months >>> eeking out a win against hopkins

[Reggie Miller]

beating hopkins>>>>tyson resume

WOW

this forum is lacking intelligent boxing fans.

[BattlingNelson]

Calzaghe has Lacy, Kessler, jones jr, eubank, hopkins

Difficult to say. Holmes had about as much left as Jones. No Holmes had a lot more left than Jones actually.

Lacy is no better than Trevor Berbick.

Hopkins i dont consider a win for Calzaghe, because imo he did not win the fight.


Eubank/Kessler

As Machine said

Berbick (WBC)
Tucker (IBF)
Bonecrusher (WBA).
Spinks (the ring)

Machine??

[BattlingNelson]

Tyson unified the HW title figting a string of alphabet champs which one by one equals Joe's wins. But Tyson has many more.

Of the top of my head:
Berbick (WBC)
Tucker (IBF)
Bonecrusher (WBA).
Spinks (the ring)

Tyson defended against the very top of his division for several years.

Calzaghe:
eubank (WBO)
Lacy (IBF)
Kessler (WBA/WBC)

Calzaghe did NOT face the best of his division every time he fought.

After Tysons loss to Douglas he was already over the hill and those losses that followed subtracts on his legacy. But I guess I'm going for Tyson as I vividly remember the terror-regime he ruled. Back then a lot of serious boxing people claimed that Tyson was greater than Ali!

Oh and since this poll doesn't include losses it HAS to be Tyson ftw.

[Dynamite Kid]

Machine??

Sorry bats i didn't look properly at who posted that. Forgive me

[boxasmash]

wow this forum sucks, calzaghe clearly has better wins than tyson.

this is embarressing.

[BattlingNelson]

wow this forum sucks, calzaghe clearly has better wins than tyson.

this is embarressing.

Great that this was a joke post. Otherwise it would be sigged all over the place....