Best All Time Fighter in Each Division

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ch@mpBox@PR
    Banned
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Feb 2008
    • 21432
    • 432
    • 279
    • 22,261

    #1

    Best All Time Fighter in Each Division

    StrawWeight - Ricardo "Finito" Lopez
    Jr. FlyWeight - Ivan "Iron Boy" Calderon
    FlyWeight - Jimmy Wilde
    Super FlyWeight - Khaosai Galaxy
    BantamWeight - Panama Al Brown
    Super BantamWeight - Wilfredo Gomez
    FeatherWeight - Willy Pep
    Super FeatherWeight - Alexis Arguello
    LighWeight - Carlos Ortiz
    Jr. WelterWeight - Nicolino Locche
    WelterWeight - Ray Leonard
    Super WelterWeight - Terry Norris
    MiddleWeight - Ray Robinson
    Super MiddleWeight - Joe Calzaghe
    Light HeavyWeight - Archie Moore
    Cruiser Weight - Evander Holyfield
    HeavyWeight - Muhammad Ali

    You can make cases for Floyd at 130, Aaron Pryor and JCC at 140, for Ray Robinson at WW,for Benitez at 154, for Hagler and Hopkins at 160 and for RJJ at 168 and 175 and for Sugar De Leon at 200!!!!!!!

    What you guys think??????
  • andrewcuff
    Banned
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Dec 2008
    • 1790
    • 83
    • 57
    • 2,078

    #2
    Originally posted by Ch@mpBox@PR
    StrawWeight - Ricardo "Finito" Lopez
    Jr. FlyWeight - Ivan "Iron Boy" Calderon
    FlyWeight - Jimmy Wilde
    Super FlyWeight - Khaosai Galaxy
    BantamWeight - Panama Al Brown
    Super BantamWeight - Wilfredo Gomez
    FeatherWeight - Willy Pep
    Super FeatherWeight - Alexis Arguello
    LighWeight - Carlos Ortiz
    Jr. WelterWeight - Nicolino Locche
    WelterWeight - Ray Leonard
    Super WelterWeight - Terry Norris
    MiddleWeight - Ray Robinson
    Super MiddleWeight - Joe Calzaghe
    Light HeavyWeight - Archie Moore
    Cruiser Weight - Evander Holyfield
    HeavyWeight - Muhammad Ali

    You can make cases for Floyd at 130, Aaron Pryor and JCC at 140, for Ray Robinson at WW,for Benitez at 154, for Hagler and Hopkins at 160 and for RJJ at 168 and 175 and for Sugar De Leon at 200!!!!!!!

    What you guys think??????
    A couple of differences:

    135: Duran or Leonard
    140: Pryor or Chavez
    147: Ray Robinson
    154: Leonard/McCallum/Hearns
    160: Hagler/Monzon

    Comment

    • PrettyBoyRoy 88
      Banned
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Jun 2008
      • 1073
      • 35
      • 40
      • 1,272

      #3
      Originally posted by Ch@mpBox@PR
      StrawWeight - Ricardo "Finito" Lopez
      Jr. FlyWeight - Ivan "Iron Boy" Calderon
      FlyWeight - Jimmy Wilde
      Super FlyWeight - Khaosai Galaxy
      BantamWeight - Panama Al Brown
      Super BantamWeight - Wilfredo Gomez
      FeatherWeight - Willy Pep
      Super FeatherWeight - Alexis Arguello
      LighWeight - Carlos Ortiz
      Jr. WelterWeight - Nicolino Locche
      WelterWeight - Ray Leonard
      Super WelterWeight - Terry Norris
      MiddleWeight - Ray Robinson
      Super MiddleWeight - Joe Calzaghe
      Light HeavyWeight - Archie Moore
      Cruiser Weight - Evander Holyfield
      HeavyWeight - Muhammad Ali

      You can make cases for Floyd at 130, Aaron Pryor and JCC at 140, for Ray Robinson at WW,for Benitez at 154, for Hagler and Hopkins at 160 and for RJJ at 168 and 175 and for Sugar De Leon at 200!!!!!!!

      What you guys think??????

      LOL after i read the thread title, i read your name and saw
      "PR". I said to myself "Okay, let me get ready to see a puerto rican boxer for each division" LOL but i was wrong. Good List. I think if Ricky Hatton beats* Pacquiao he can make a case for Best JWW of all time

      Comment

      • Ishy Aytan
        Undisputed Champion
        • Apr 2008
        • 2184
        • 66
        • 64
        • 8,726

        #4
        Originally posted by Ch@mpBox@PR
        StrawWeight - Ricardo "Finito" Lopez
        Jr. FlyWeight - Ivan "Iron Boy" Calderon
        FlyWeight - Jimmy Wilde
        Super FlyWeight - Khaosai Galaxy
        BantamWeight - Panama Al Brown
        Super BantamWeight - Wilfredo Gomez
        FeatherWeight - Willy Pep
        Super FeatherWeight - Alexis Arguello
        LighWeight - Carlos Ortiz
        Jr. WelterWeight - Nicolino Locche
        WelterWeight - Ray Leonard
        Super WelterWeight - Terry Norris
        MiddleWeight - Ray Robinson
        Super MiddleWeight - Joe Calzaghe
        Light HeavyWeight - Archie Moore
        Cruiser Weight - Evander Holyfield
        HeavyWeight - Muhammad Ali

        You can make cases for Floyd at 130, Aaron Pryor and JCC at 140, for Ray Robinson at WW,for Benitez at 154, for Hagler and Hopkins at 160 and for RJJ at 168 and 175 and for Sugar De Leon at 200!!!!!!!

        What you guys think??????


        Good list.

        Couple of adjustments:

        Supper Feather: Floyd Mayweather Jr
        Lightweight: Duran
        Light Welter: Aaron Pryor
        Supper Middle: Jones Jr ( he would have dominated the division if he had decided to stay on in it).

        Comment

        • andrewcuff
          Banned
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Dec 2008
          • 1790
          • 83
          • 57
          • 2,078

          #5
          Originally posted by Ishy Aytan
          Good list.

          Couple of adjustments:

          Super Feather: Floyd Mayweather Jr
          Lightweight: Duran
          Light Welter: Aaron Pryor
          Supper Middle: Jones Jr ( he would have dominated the division if he had decided to stay on in it).
          More than Arguello?

          Comment

          • Ishy Aytan
            Undisputed Champion
            • Apr 2008
            • 2184
            • 66
            • 64
            • 8,726

            #6
            Originally posted by kev183
            LOL after i read the thread title, i read your name and saw
            "PR". I said to myself "Okay, let me get ready to see a puerto rican boxer for each division" LOL but i was wrong. Good List. I think if Ricky Hatton beats* Pacquiao he can make a case for Best JWW of all time

            Why because Pacquiao's a bonafide 140 pounder?

            Comment

            • Ch@mpBox@PR
              Banned
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Feb 2008
              • 21432
              • 432
              • 279
              • 22,261

              #7
              Originally posted by Ishy Aytan
              Good list.

              Couple of adjustments:

              Supper Feather: Floyd Mayweather Jr
              Lightweight: Duran
              Light Welter: Aaron Pryor
              Supper Middle: Jones Jr ( he would have dominated the division if he had decided to stay on in it).
              I agree, but he didnt stay and Zaghe, had a 20 defenses run!!!!!!!

              Comment

              • PrettyBoyRoy 88
                Banned
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Jun 2008
                • 1073
                • 35
                • 40
                • 1,272

                #8
                Originally posted by Ishy Aytan
                Why because Pacquiao's a bonafide 140 pounder?
                No because he will be 45-1 at jr welterweight which no one in jww is even close to..and a win over pacquiao, for Hatton shoud catapult his P4P status as high as stars(not number 1) but a very close to 1

                EDIT: 45-0 at JWW if he beats Pacman
                Last edited by PrettyBoyRoy 88; 03-20-2009, 07:53 PM.

                Comment

                • street bully
                  Tua's daddy.
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Jan 2008
                  • 25014
                  • 697
                  • 263
                  • 35,118

                  #9
                  List is fine for the most part, but I would have Duran at 135, SRR was the best WW of all times and he should be there. Hagler at 160.

                  Comment

                  • andrewcuff
                    Banned
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Dec 2008
                    • 1790
                    • 83
                    • 57
                    • 2,078

                    #10
                    Originally posted by street bully
                    List is fine for the most part, but I would have Duran at 135, SRR was the best WW of all times and he should be there. Hagler at 160.
                    Good shout!

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP