Pacquiao or Hopkins, Who has the better Resume? Poll!

[DrewWoodside]

These seem to be the two most prominent results from a thread asking the most impressive resume post the year 2000. So who has the better resume and why? Bernard Hopkins or Manny Pacquiao? I think this topic is very debatable.. In my personal opinion it is also very clear. BTW having the better resume doesn't necessarily indicate the better fighter so lets just focus on resumes. Please discuss, Poll to follow!

Some Notable Wins for each fighter:

Bernard Hopkins
Winky Wright
Antonio Tarver
Felix Trinidad
Kelly Pavlik
Oscar De La Hoya
Glen Johnson
William Joppy

Manny Pacquiao
Juan Manuel Marquez 1-0-1
Marco Antonio Barrera 2-0
Oscar De La Hoya
Eric Morales 2-1
Lehlohonolo ledwaba
David Diaz
Jorge Solis

[dans]

Right now, Hopkins, eventually Pacman will surpass him though.

[andrewcuff]

Right now, Hopkins, eventually Pacman will surpass him though.

Quite possible. In a year or two Pacquiao could have an extremely impressive resume.

[hammerhiem]

Both have great resume's.

Pac can end his career with a better resume than BHop but presently Bhop has the best resume of all current fighters.

[andrewcuff]

Both have great resume's.

Pac can end his career with a better resume than BHop but presently Bhop has the best resume of all current fighters.

Yep. End thread.

[DrewWoodside]

Both have great resume's.

Pac can end his career with a better resume than BHop but presently Bhop has the best resume of all current fighters.

So Pacquiao is like A-Rod chasing B. Bond's(Hopkins) homerun record(Resume). Bonds is still ahead but in all likeliehood A-Rod will surpass and then some.

[hammerhiem]

So Pacquiao is like A-Rod chasing B. Bond's(Hopkins) homerun record(Resume). Bonds is still ahead but in all likeliehood A-Rod will surpass and then some.

Sure if you want to put it like that.

A-Rod will surpass Bonds unless he has a serious injury or loss of form (gets beat by Hatton and JMM in a rematch), most likely he will surpass it.

[S.G.]

i still think B-Hop's will be ahead of PAcman's after Pac smashes Hatton

when/if Pac beats Marquez decisively it will put him around equal, and if he beats Mayweather he will surpass B-Hop

that's the way i look at it

in Pacman's 3 biggest fights he's 1-1-1 (beat Barrera, drew with JMM and lost to Morales)

[-----------]

i still think B-Hop's will be ahead of PAcman's after Pac smashes Hatton

when/if Pac beats Marquez decisively it will put him around equal, and if he beats Mayweather he will surpass B-Hop

that's the way i look at it

in Pacman's 3 biggest fights he's 1-1-1 (beat Barrera, drew with JMM and lost to Morales)

You don't count De La Hoya as one of Pacquiao's biggest fights?

It was his biggest fight in terms of worldwide exposure, money earned, and PPV's gained. It was also his biggest challenge to date.

[aether]

i still think B-Hop's will be ahead of PAcman's after Pac smashes Hatton

when/if Pac beats Marquez decisively it will put him around equal, and if he beats Mayweather he will surpass B-Hop

that's the way i look at it

in Pacman's 3 biggest fights he's 1-1-1 (beat Barrera, drew with JMM and lost to Morales)

won againts de la hoya
won againts JMM
won twice againts Morales

edit: won twice againts barrera