Amir Khan is a P4P fighter

[FeFist]

so if Khans defence was great and he had a really good chin, you could still name 5 fighters that would beat him.

These are the attributes that make a good boxer so no you can't call him a good boxer.

That's like saying. If I had a good offence, chin and defence I'd be a world class boxer.

[UnDeniable]

His defence will improve

His Chin will also improve when he moves up in weight

[-Mustang-]

so if Khans defence was great and he had a really good chin, you could still name 5 fighters that would beat him.

no and that's the point... he doesn't have good defense or a good chin

[sebspeed]

I don't think Amir Khan will ever be a P4P fighter,he will be a good lightweight,not even one of the top 3,but he will be a good contender for anybody, he doesn't have the chin to be a P4P or even one of the top 3 lightweight at the moment.

[youngswish23]

no way p4p. hes a great prospect with talent but he has to beat prescott in a rematch to redeem himself that ko was nasty! but i would love to see him fight edwin valero or juan diaz. he has the speed to give anybody problems but his chin is very suspect.

[-----------]

These are the attributes that make a good boxer so no you can't call him a good boxer.

That's like saying. If I had a good offence, chin and defence I'd be a world class boxer.

no and that's the point... he doesn't have good defense or a good chin

I'm talking about his offensive skills, they are P4P.

I'm not saying he's a P4P fighter NOW, thats ****ing ******.

[marvelous1]

why does everyone think amir kunt is the best now. look guys he beat a washed up legend it doesnt meen his the best juan diaz would pressure that pakistani ass to death

[badnewsbrown]

how can you rate his offensive skills so highly. to me he looked amatuer, as usual. it wont work against the top fighters

[revs1227]

not even close .......
jmm
diaz
valero
prescot
guzman

all lightweight who would beat him mostly by ko

p4p?
no shotttttttt

[hammerhiem]

He's not even top 10 at lightweight.