Hatton V Mosley @ 140

[Welter_Skelter]

If we are talking about a 37 year old Mosley... and he has to get down to 140???

I think that would be too much.. and Hatton would win..

at 147?? Mosley would win by KO..

[phoneboothboxer]

i dunno... i see the point of SSM actually making it to 140, it'll be a little bit of hard work... but if he has a little while to get there, he might be able to pull it off... he's got excellent work ethic, and i haven't really seen him tired in a bout... that's why i knew he'd beat Margo(not trying to get a discussion about him started)... but anyways, at 147 it's definitely a Mosley KO... at 140? given ample time, i feel the same thing would happen... he knows how to hit Hatton and hit him again, i don't think the Hitman can take SSM's power...

[Pugilistic™]

If Mosley could make 140 without no bad effects he would destroy Hatton.

Mosley by KO.

I see no way that Mosley could make 140 at this stage though.

[Mr. Philadel]

If you have shane mosley listed as one of your favourite fighter i guess you are a bit biased

even Ricky's fans knows what is the likely outcome.....

Shane by one of the most brutal KO's you'll ever see......it'll make what he did to Marg look like foreplay

[Dave Rado]

If Mosley could make 140 without no bad effects he would destroy Hatton.

Mosley by KO.

I see no way that Mosley could make 140 at this stage though.

That's been my point all along. If that's really what the OP meant, then I don't see how he can possibly be favourite to win.

NB - I haven't voted because the OP still hasn't made it clear if that is what he really meant.

[Derranged]

Isn't the idea a fantasy matchup between a peak Mosley when he was at Lightweight, if he'd moved up to 140 at that time, vs. a peak Hatton? If so, Mosley by late KO. But if the idea is that Mosley has to boil down to 140 now, then Hatton by TKO.

I believe its more of a fantasy matchup like you said. No way should Mosley go down to 140 now.

But peak for peak, Mosley wins late TKO.

[jdubb863]

They would hug each other to a draw

[Rubber Duck]

who you got?

I dont think mosley will be that good down there.

[toysale]

i fancy a body blow from hatton to get to him in latter rounds, hatton tko (if we're talking about this fight as something happening now rather than when they're at their peaks).

[Dave Rado]

I believe its more of a fantasy matchup like you said. No way should Mosley go down to 140 now.

But peak for peak, Mosley wins late TKO.

I agree that it should be, but as the OP hasn't made it clear, I think any vote is meaningless until he does.