Sport Illustrated.com's Top 10 fighters P4P

[Eric Holder]

what a bad list

[elfag]

Dawson is WAY too high. I dont know about Darchiniyan being in there, his last fight while a win wasnt that great.

I would really consider putting Wlad in the top 10. People seem to always to not even consider heavyweights in p4p lists which isnt always fair. Wlad is skilled and dominate in his division so I think he makes the top 10.

I would probably have Hopkins infront of mosley. I do like that they respected JMM and gave him a high ranking. I think that is fair being that he had a very close fight with Pacman who is no doubt number one. You cant have someone have a near draw with the p4p #1 then go on to have 2 impressive KO wins and give the guy a #5 p4p ranking, it just isnt right.

[MEXGBP]

dawson should not be in the list
those guy are crazy
I would put william or klisko over dawson

[HOMETOWNCHAMP]

I really dont think anyone should have Mosley in there top 3. I think that Dawson and Pavlik are kinda high as well.

[DarchinyFAN]

Dawson is WAY too high. I dont know about Darchiniyan being in there, his last fight while a win wasnt that great.

I would really consider putting Wlad in the top 10. People seem to always to not even consider heavyweights in p4p lists which isnt always fair. Wlad is skilled and dominate in his division so I think he makes the top 10.

I would probably have Hopkins infront of mosley. I do like that they respected JMM and gave him a high ranking. I think that is fair being that he had a very close fight with Pacman who is no doubt number one. You cant have someone have a near draw with the p4p #1 then go on to have 2 impressive KO wins and give the guy a #5 p4p ranking, it just isnt right.

Dunno how you can say the blue statement and then turn around and say the red one.

[SickmyDuck]

How is Paul Williams not worthy of being on there????

He beat Margarito...who slaughtered cotto.

Moved up and won a title in LMW and even went up to MW....

only has 1 lost...which he avenged in a first round knockout

Get the **** outta here

He won an interim title against a 40 year old Verno Phillips

Dzinziruk is the real champion

He went up to middleweight and beat a stiff

Williams is overrated Ethiopian trash