Can we ALL AGREE that if Hatton wins, He has Earned His Rematch with PBF?

[MANGLER]

No point to that fight. He can't beat PBF.

[fallenloki]

honestly, i dont care how he lost..everybody has a bad night....
look at Williams vs. Quintana...

I am just a firm believer that a fighter should always get a chance to redeem himself. And if hatton beats Pac,,I think he has earn that right...

no body in boxing is better than Pacquaio right now, so if hatton beats him, how can anybody say he didnt earn his shot back at floyd...

My thinking is if he some how beats Pacquaio, then that means he has learn from that lost with floyd and became a better fighter for it,,,
Dont you guys think so,,,,If Hatton beats Pacquaio then he has improved instead of stay the same??

He would have to beat the holy hell out of Manny and show a completely different skill-set under the guidance of Floyd Sr. Even then, Floyd Sr. has already stated that he would not train Hatton against Floyd Jr. Having said that, I sincerely believe that Manny KO's Hatton in the middle rounds of their fight.

Hypothetically speaking, if everything went Hatton's way and he got the rematch he'd get KO'd by floyd again and earlier this time..

[Saloth Sar]

So i guess nobody wants to see a Pavlik vs. Hopkins rematch either ...


So who Should Mayweather fight if Pacquaio loses....

becaus My boy Cotto still havent redeem himself against Margarito...
and a Mosely fight doesnt seem like it will happen since those two have bad history with each other...

I guess floyd next fight will be JMM if pac loses.. ;-/

[savorduhflavor]

Floyd is a whole other animal compared to Pac...

If Hatton beats a smaller man in Pac, than he's ready to get back in with his daddy? That doesn't make sense to me.

You bring up Paul Williams/Quintana...that was a close fight. And it was the type of fight that left you feeling that Paul Williams was certainly capable of winning....you didn't get that sense after Hatton/Floyd.

There is no need for a Hatton/Floyd rematch. Hatton beating Pac doesn't change that.

[Pullcounter]

no... hatton needs to get in line behind of mosley and cotto, or he needs to beat them and take their place.

[Saloth Sar]

He would have to beat the holy hell out of Manny and show a completely different skill-set under the guidance of Floyd Sr. Even then, Floyd Sr. has already stated that he would not train Hatton against Floyd Jr. Having said that, I sincerely believe that Manny KO's Hatton in the middle rounds of their fight.

Hypothetically speaking, if everything went Hatton's way and he got the rematch he'd get KO'd by floyd again and earlier this time..

Personally I just think Hatton gets way to much **** on for losing to Mayweather.........You guys treat him like a bum every sense he lost to floyd...It is no shame in losing to the best fighter in the world at the time..

And If i was Hatton I would win a rematch too...**** no other fight would interest me but a rematch with Floyd...

And honestly if you guys were Hatton you would want a rematch too...

every fighter if given the oppurtunity should get the chance to redeem himself...Thats what makes boxing the best sport in the world...
No matter what anybody can be beat...anybody... even floyd...

[Saloth Sar]

no... hatton needs to get in line behind of mosley and cotto, or he needs to beat them and take their place.

Get in line?
Mosely could have fought floyd but he turn it down
Cotto from what i read also turn down a fight with floyd...


Look The 2 fights i want too see the most are
1. Pacquiao vs. Floyd
2. Cotto vs. Floyd
Check my record,,,,



But I am a fair minded person and if hatton beats Pacquaio IMo.....
he has earn it,,, I mean I understand alot of people want to see floyd lose and all.. but honestly that should not cloud your judgement in deciding wheter or not if Rick Hatton should get a remacth...

I mean Hatton pressure was affecting Floyd,,,but his problem was he did not set up his offense with no jab or move his head... but those are fixable errors...

Fair is Fair..and if a fighter loses to a fighter and proves that he is a still a great fighter in his next fight.. then he should get a remacth...


but i guess fair has nothing to do with Hatton to some of you guys

[My Name Is...]

So Saloth... Why should Hatton get a fight with Floyd before Cotto and Mosley???

EDIT.... i can understand you saying Mosley had his shot and didnt take it... But what about Cotto?? He turned Floyd down at 140... This is 147...

[Burner]

Pacquaio vs. Hatton. IF Hatton wins, Has He earned PBF rematch??

or Do you guys think a rematch with Floyd still should not Happen???


Let's Discuss.

Anyone who votes no is a dumbass...period.

If he smacks Manny( the p4p king)_ around the ring how the hell does he not deserve to fight Floyd fght again and avenge his only loss.

[Saloth Sar]

So Saloth... Why should Hatton get a fight with Floyd before Cotto and Mosley???

My dude honestly I like cotto alot...
and i think he can beat floyd,,,,if they fought 5 times, i think cotto could win 1 of them...

but thats not my point.


My point is Fair is Fair,, and if Hatton beats the p4p #1 fighter in the sport
why shouldnt he get a rematch to the only guy he ever lost too???

I dont let my opinion on Floyd change my morals on what i think is right and wrong... Period.

And i think if hatton wins i think it would be right for him and floyd to make a rematch... because it is the right thing to do..and that is what boxing is all about...



and for mosley...i think he might still have a toothache..