Latest Ring Mag P4P (as of 3/1/2009): Pac still #1, JMM #2

[Pacdbest]

Cotto exited the list when he lost to Margarito and a win over Jennings isn't good enough to put him back on. Hatton dominated the #1 rated guy at his weight and deserves to be on the list.

Cotto was beaten By Marga Cheato. I Pick Cheato to beat Cotto but This is about ratings. Cheato's gone. I Give Cotto the benefit of the doubt. He still got Mosley, Quintana & a lot of Good former undefeated guys in his resume.

[Kris Silver]

We should remeber Hatton was p4p top 5 was he not, before losing to the p4p #1. Usually folk losing go down a few places, he got totally thrown out, and losing to the best fighter in the world. So you can see it as a correction long term if you like.

As for Cotto, I don't know how he's suddenly not even in the top 10. He remained in there after a loss, yet he gets a win and is out, wtf? Shane is too high for one win too, way too high.

[$partacus]

Cotto was beaten By Marga Cheato. I Pick Cheato to beat Cotto but This is about ratings. Cheato's gone. I Give Cotto the benefit of the doubt. He still got Mosley, Quintana & a lot of Good former undefeated guys in his resume.

I don't think Cotto should have been taken off the list, but he was and a win over Jennings isn't good enough to put him back on IMO

[El Ceja]

it's fair!!!

[DarchinyFAN]

Other than my usual objections to Calderon (I've gone over this before, and his fans & I will never agree), and a slight objection to Caballero (but I can see the argument for him). I think the list is fine.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

That list Sucks, Calderon shoul be top 5, Cotto should be there at number 8, Rafa Marquez is ridiculously high, he should be 9 or 10 and Cabellero should not be there

This is how the list shoiuld look like

1.Pacquiao
2.JMM
3.B-Hop
4.Calderon
5.Vazquez
6.Molsey
7.Cotto
8.Darchinyan
9.Hatton
10.Marquez

[NAPO]

rafael marque needs to get the **** out of that list. seriously the ring is getting phony.

hatton would be fine at 9 or 10 but caballero?

[Pullcounter]

hatton shouldnt be on the list... he wasnt last issue right?

[$partacus]

hatton shouldnt be on the list... he wasnt last issue right?

He was,i think he's been on since Malignaggi fight.

[-Antonio-]

Why? because he beat jennings?

Cotto exited the list when he lost to Margarito and a win over Jennings isn't good enough to put him back on. Hatton dominated the #1 rated guy at his weight and deserves to be on the list.

Maybe Cotto losing shouldnt have taken him off the list in the first place? The "number one guy" at Hatton's weight was already beaten by Cotto.
And he wasn't that good.