What was more the convincing win? PBF over Castillo Twice vs Pacman over JMM Twice

**KnockoutTheFat** · 03-01-2009, 06:58 PM

Any Paul Williams win.

**Carolina Bomber** · 03-01-2009, 07:00 PM

Originally posted by Marvelous Floyd

Mayweather � Castillo.
Mayweathers first fight at 135 against best LW at the time. Mayweather fought the first fight with an injured shoulder and won. Many people questioned the decision. Mayweather gave him an immediate rematch and proved doubters wrong,

JMM � PACMAN
First fight was at 125. Many people thought JMM had done enough to win. Rematch happens years later at 130. Pacman gets the nod, yet the majority of the boxing world scored it for JMM still. And Pacman has questions still hanging over his head about JMM

Well it would've been Pacman over JMM twice, except he only beat him once. And that fight could have gone either way.

**Bhopreign** · 03-01-2009, 07:00 PM

Originally posted by Marvelous Floyd

Mayweather � Castillo.
Mayweathers first fight at 135 against best LW at the time. Mayweather fought the first fight with an injured shoulder and won. Many people questioned the decision. Mayweather gave him an immediate rematch and proved doubters wrong,

JMM � PACMAN
First fight was at 125. Many people thought JMM had done enough to win. Rematch happens years later at 130. Pacman gets the nod, yet the majority of the boxing world scored it for JMM still. And Pacman has questions still hanging over his head about JMM

Not to mention Floyd's cracked ribs.

**AztecWanker** · 03-01-2009, 07:02 PM

Floyd, no question.

**Left Hook Tua** · 03-01-2009, 07:02 PM

manny's win over oscar delahoya was more convincing than floyd's win.

**Pullcounter** · 03-01-2009, 07:03 PM

Originally posted by Marvelous Floyd

Mayweather � Castillo.
Mayweathers first fight at 135 against best LW at the time. Mayweather fought the first fight with an injured shoulder and won. Many people questioned the decision. Mayweather gave him an immediate rematch and proved doubters wrong,

JMM � PACMAN
First fight was at 125. Many people thought JMM had done enough to win. Rematch happens years later at 130. Pacman gets the nod, yet the majority of the boxing world scored it for JMM still. And Pacman has questions still hanging over his head about JMM

mayweather's win are more convincing, but pac actually put jmm on his asss 5 times.

**Left Hook Tua** · 03-01-2009, 07:04 PM

Originally posted by KOTheFat

Any Paul Williams win.

paul williams has fought more natural middleweights than floyd has welterweights.

true story.

**�ringer** · 03-01-2009, 07:04 PM

Mayweather's wins over Castillo are more convincing than Pacquiao's draw and "win" over Marquez.

**KnockoutTheFat** · 03-01-2009, 07:05 PM

Originally posted by Left Hook Tua

paul williams has fought more natural middleweights than floyd has welterweights.

true story.

That we can agree on. And he's actually got into the ring and beat those MW's.

What was more the convincing win? PBF over Castillo Twice vs Pacman over JMM Twice