Which Quintana-Williams fight was more of a "Fluke"

[MANGLER]

Neither. CQ outboxed him once and got KTFO once. Pwill did him in wit an onslaught, not just 1 lucky bomb. Can't call either fight a fluke imo.

[The Gambler1981]

Quintana was generous enough to give Williams an immediate rematch..

Your logic is very flawed and seems to be based on insecurity

The 2nd flight was a total fluke.. if it wasn't.. then a 3rd fight will clearly prove that..

HAHA, Paul Williams is a piss poor boxer by the way. Any good technical boxer, should not have real problems with him aslong as they can keep up.

Williams had a rematch clause, no? So Quintana had to give him a rematch..

He hit him cleanly, he went down. Where is the fluke?

[Electrode]

OK..I keep seeing Paul Williams fans claiming the first fight against Quintana was a "fluke" and showed his true Potential in the rematch!..but I really don't understand this logic..how can you call a 12 round schooling a fluke?..
Quintana was moving, circling and popping Williams ALL NIGHT!..he was ROCKING Williams with that looping left hand ALL NIGHT!..

So Quintana wasn't suppose to win that fight..and the rematch was almost inevitable!..and Quintana I believe steps in a lil too confident and felt he could stand and trade this time around and Williams catches him clean in the first Round and puts him away..

I think In my opinion of course that the second fight was the showcase of a real "fluke" as it was more of Quintana's ****iness/Williams determination that clashed that night..

what do you guys think?...

Niether was a fluke.

Williams lost the first fight..made adjustments..and took him out in the rematch.

Why is that so hard for you haters to accept???

I bet if Cotto came back and stopped Tony in one round you wouldn't be talking that fluke ****..lol

[Electrode]

lets get a third fight on to see...oh wait, Williams wants no part of that

Oh really?

It was Quintana that didnt want the 3rd fight

[egreezy]

How common are 12 round UD's?

How common are 1st round KO's in 12 round (championship level) Fights?

The answer is pretty obvious what is the more fluky occurrence..

how many UD wins does Quintana have against elite level competition?
How many times has he been stopped by elite level competition? Twice Cotto and Williams. I think he's been stopped more times than he has wins against other elite.

[Electrode]

None, Knocking someone in the first round doesnt mean its a fluke unless you dont know boxing, And schooling someone in a 12 round fight isnt a fluke neither.

Defination of a fluke- something good that has happened that is the result of chance instead/rather of skill or planning..

co-sign...

[Welter_Skelter]

Niether was a fluke.

Williams lost the first fight..made adjustments..and took him out in the rematch.

Why is that so hard for you haters to accept???

I bet if Cotto came back and stopped Tony in one round you wouldn't be talking that fluke ****..lol

I most certainly would call Cotto knocking out a Marg in 1 round a fluke..

Do it twice.. and I am convinced .. Until then.. Championship level fights that end in 1 round are NOT the norm.. statistically making them Flukes.. it's not even an opinion.. It's math

[Addition]

Neither was a fluke. In the 2nd fight Williams was landing bombs before he KO'd Quintant so i'm suprised people consider that a fluke.

[Electrode]

I most certainly would call Cotto knocking out a Marg in 1 round a fluke..

Do it twice.. and I am convinced .. Until then.. Championship level fights that end in 1 round are NOT the norm.. statistically making them Flukes.. it's not even an opinion.. It's math

It's your fuzzy math.

Stop trying to steal that great victory from Williams..it won't work anyway.

[NAPO]

Oh really?

It was Quintana that didnt want the 3rd fight

it was williams buddy.quintana got denied of the fight because of williams recognizing the risk of a 3rd fight with quintana.