(EXPOSE THREAD):LEGITIMATE reason’s to question a Fighter’s CREDIBILITY!

[Horus]

(EXPOSE THREAD): Legitimate reason’s to question a Fighter’s credibility as a great fighter THREAD..!!

Lately I have been I laying back and just been reading the line of hate and reasoning that some fans give to some fighters and not others.
Most of it is Hating just to Hate.
I.E (He is a bum, He is a *****) with no explanations. TIME TO END ALL THAT.

This Thread is about giving legitimate arguments and claims into why you think a fighters credibility as a great fighter should be question..!


Now My hope is that this thread allows us to really have a decent discussion into why some fighters credibility should be question in a civil way, without this thread getting Flame out….

So let the EXPOSING BEGIN!!!

[The Rican]

This isn't any groundbreaking material.

Anyone claiming fighters are bums or ******* get the ignore.

Why try to have an intelligent discussion with someone who isn't in the know?

Why go through this ridiculous ten question process?

[nathan_nall]

I wore a sock with a whole in it to work today. Right in the middle of a staffing, my big toe slipped out. Isn't that the absolute worst feeling in the world?

[El Dominicano]

I don't hate any fighter. I like to snap on Calzaghe though

[The Gambler1981]

Lots of people throw around words without really thinking what they mean bum, journeyman, joke, cab driver, clown, great, GOAT, ATG, unbeatable ect. ect. ect.. That is the big part of the problem, like when someone calls Arturo Gatti a bum, now is he a world beater no, is he really that great no, but he still has enough quality to be nowhere near a bum. Just an example, and it works both ways to be honest.

[Horus]

The first fighter who's credibility who should be questioned is
the PLASTER MAN himself Margarita <-- straight ***** now for what he got caught attempting to do...!!

1. Margarito would not go into the hall of fame if he retired as is.
2. Margarito best defense is his chin, and it has been that way from day 1
3. He should have at least been a undisputed champion once in the WW division since he has been there his whole career
4. The biggest misconception about Margarito is that he had a chin of steel
5. Margarito ranks probably 15 top in his era at the ww division... but maybe not no more since he has been found out to be a cheater.
6. Yes, he beat cotto. I thought hr would lose if cotto would have just boxed him
7. He should hqave fought people his own size like 160 pounders which he is...
he should have been have move up at least 2 division by now.
8.Yes
9.Yes
10. Has no fundamental boxing skill..!!!

Margarito should not be considered a great fighter IMO...

[Horus]

This isn't any groundbreaking material.

Anyone claiming fighters are bums or ******* get the ignore.

Why try to have an intelligent discussion with someone who isn't in the know?

Why go through this ridiculous ten question process?

You dont have to answer none of the questions... but i just want to have a real discussion about which fighters do you think should be discredited..!!

[BlackHat]

I wore a sock with a whole in it to work today. Right in the middle of a staffing, my big toe slipped out. Isn't that the absolute worst feeling in the world?

I feel yah!

[The Rican]

You can't possibly expect to run that many discussions concurrently within one thread. Especially not on this forum. Let people discuss it on there own. They can figure it out for themselves.

[AntonTheMeh]

horus, nobody takes you seriously.that boat debacle was your plaster-gate.
you are finished as a poster on boxingscene.

and to answer your question, time will tell.it always does.it has for all of them.now go young fella, go and spread the goodwill of mayweather by building houses on boats, go! spread the word!