How would you rate as a bigger ATG- PBF or PAC

[hammerhiem]

Both are in the 50-20 bracket.

Resume = Pretty close, Pac just I think.
Longevity = Pac
Skills = PBF
Accomplishments = Pac
Intangables = PBF

[FasTHarD]

Simple as..........

I vote on the pretty obvious the better comp and better resume...
Manny Pacman Pacquiao.... Mayweather is no way near...

[Oasis_Lad]

Manny's resume > Floyd's.

[FasTHarD]

Pacquiao has been knocked out by a stick figure. He is not even in Mayweather's league. The fact Pacquiao is in the lead in the poll suggests that boxingscene is full of people who do not understand boxing. I do not care about either one. I just like technical skill and greatness. Mayweather>Pacquiao all day, every day, 25/8

Martin Castillo beat the **** out of Floyd he was amateur 106 pounds....

[hotshoes]

pbf for now but pac would be higher than him if he gets by hatton imo

[Burning Desire]

Manny Pacquiao's accomplishments are far greater then Floyd's.. even if they are against old Mexicans.
Barrera
Morales
Marquez

and if he gets by Hatton he will have **** on the two greatest things Mayweather done..
that is De La Hoya and Hatton.

Manny Pacquiao may have the best single wins but overall, Floyd Mayweather has the better resume. Until Manny Pacquiao defeated MAB his resume wasn't anything worth talking about. The facts are here just take a look.

Floyd Mayweather

Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo x2
Genaro Hernandez
Carlos Hernandez
ODLH
Ricky Hatton
Zab Judah
Arturo Gatti
Angel Manfredy
Victoriano Sosa
Sharmba Mitchell

World titles Super Featherweight 8 defenses, Lightweight 3 defenses, Jr Welterweight 2 defenses, Jr Middleweight.

Manny Pacquiao

ODLH
David Diaz
JMM
Erik Morales x2
MAB x2
Jorge Solis
Oscar Larios
Jorge Elicer Solis

World titles Flyweight 1 defense, Super Bantamweight 5 defenses, Super Featherweight, Lightweight.

Manny Pacquiao lacks the defenses and the overall resume.

[MELLY-MEL...]

manny's resume ftw

[Pacdbest]

Ok Lol

So where is your argument??? Can you disprove my statement???

[Ishy Aytan]

Manny Pacquiao may have the best single wins but overall, Floyd Mayweather has the better resume. Until Manny Pacquiao defeated MAB his resume wasn't anything worth talking about. The facts are here just take a look.

Floyd Mayweather

Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo x2
Genaro Hernandez
Carlos Hernandez
ODLH
Ricky Hatton
Zab Judah
Arturo Gatti
Angel Manfredy
Victoriano Sosa
Sharmba Mitchell

World titles Super Featherweight 8 defenses, Lightweight 3 defenses, Jr Welterweight 2 defenses, Jr Middleweight.

Manny Pacquiao

ODLH
David Diaz
JMM
Erik Morales x2
MAB x2
Jorge Solis
Oscar Larios
Jorge Elicer Solis

World titles Flyweight 1 defense, Super Bantamweight 5 defenses, Super Featherweight, Lightweight.

Manny Pacquiao lacks the defenses and the overall resume.

Floyds resume is underrated. His resume is better than Pac's. Floyd at the moment is a higher atg than Pacman.

I think the experts will also have Floyd higher than Pac. Actually i am sure of it.

[Sugar May Floyd]

Pacman has two questionable decision over JMM and Floyd has one only over Castillo a fight where he had an injured shoulder. Pacman gets credit beating Oscar at a weight he had not fought in 7 years. Why Mayweather gets discredited by beating Hatton at 147, a weight where he won a title at recently.

Oscar at 154 > Oscar 147
Hatton at 140 > Hatton 147