How would you rate as a bigger ATG- PBF or PAC

[DUnknown1]

I pic PBF only because he has a more extensive career than Pac.
But I know this thread is gonna get heated once all the Pac nuthugers are aware of it.
Face it nuthugers Pac is good but he still has a long way to match PBF.

[Sin City]

Floyd is virtually flawless in the ring and in the off chance he does make a mistake he corrects it immediately.

Manny on the other hand does not have the ability seeing as he goofed against JMM twice. May had an off night against castillio but came back the 2nd time around and dominated.

the thing is it's not about who looks better or who has more flaws then the other.. when you talk about legacy you talk about accomplishments. the argument of atg boils down to accomplishments.. so who beat/fought the better opposition.

[Sin City]

I pic PBF only because he has a more extensive career than Pac.
But I know this thread is gonna get heated once all the Pac nuthugers are aware of it.
Face it nuthugers Pac is good but he still has a long way to match PBF.

Mayweathers greatest wins:
De La Hoya
Hatton
Corrales
Castillo
Chavez

Manny Pacquiao's:
Morales
Barrera
Marquez
De La Hoya
and if he gets by him, Hatton.

Marquez, Barrera, and Morales are much better wins then Castillo, Corrales and Chavez.

[Saloth Sar]

pac had more legendary fights and feats

i dont feel like looking up stats...
But what is the most title defenses Pacquaio has ever had in 1 division?
I know Floyd had 8 @ 130...
and I think 5 @ 135..
So what is the most PAC had in 1 division????
I am really curious

[Saloth Sar]

i dont feel like looking up stats...
But what is the most title defenses Pacquaio has ever had in 1 division?
I know Floyd had 8 @ 130...
and I think 5 @ 135..
So what is the most PAC had in 1 division????
I am really curious

Anyone....?

[Sin City]

Anyone....?

not too sure but it doesn't matter how many times you defend but who you defend against.
belts don't mean ish either.. it's who you fight.

take calzaghe for example.. he defended his belt many many times.. but the people he defended against where the likes of Sakio Bika and Peter Manfredo.

Should Calzaghe get as much credit for those two defenses as someone who defended a title against stronger op?

[Saloth Sar]

not too sure but it doesn't matter how many times you defend but who you defend against.
belts don't mean ish either.. it's who you fight.

take calzaghe for example.. he defended his belt many many times.. but the people he defended against where the likes of Sakio Bika and Peter Manfredo.

Should Calzaghe get as much credit for those two defenses as someone who defended a title against stronger op?

ok but thats not answering my question.
How many times did Pacquaio Defend his titles?
In order to be a complete champion you have to defend your title.
So what are the hard facts of Pacquaio defending any of his titles in 1 division....

PLEASE dont respond unless you have that answer ready.
NO HATE.... I just want a Answer to my question.

[WaRCoTTo]

as of now mayweather. couple more big wins for pacman and that will change

That's exactly what it is!..

If Pac manages to get past Hatton..and maybe JMM again (more convincingly!)..and one more MEGA-FIGHT wit PBF himself!..he becomes top 20 ATG IMO!..

[We want Floyd]

ok but thats not answering my question.
How many times did Pacquaio Defend his titles?
In order to be a complete champion you have to defend your title.
So what are the hard facts of Pacquaio defending any of his titles in 1 division....

PLEASE dont respond unless you have that answer ready.
NO HATE.... I just want a Answer to my question.

Who do you give more credit to, a fighter who had better opposition or a fighter who defended a title multiple times?

That's basically what it boils down to?

There's no debating that PAC has the better resume.

There's no debating that Ugly Boy Floyd had more title defenses.

Again, who do you give more credit to?

** I pick the fighter who fought the best, not because he defended his title against random contenders.

[DUnknown1]

that's exactly what it is!..

If pac manages to get past hatton..and maybe jmm again (more convincingly!)..and one more mega-fight wit pbf himself!..he becomes top 20 atg imo!..

agreed !!!!!!!!!!