Who ranks higher all time, Lewis or Calzaghe?

[nathan_nall]

Lewis faced stiffer competition. Despite the U.S. consensus... Joe HAS faced many excellent fighters, in their primes.... but just not as many as Lewis.

[El Dominicano]

Barry McGuigan also says Calzaghe is better.

Well Boxamash and Barry McGuigan are the only people in that boat. Ofcourse they'll be a few other idiots

[boxasmash]

calzaghe... easily.

[Bushbaby]

I may get it for this,but I must say they are about the same,probably Lewis by a hair,based on opposition,I think most people may be biased to JC because of his fans,but then there are fans of other fighters who havent fought the best that are undefeated and retired and would still speak of the greatness of their fighter then dis JC for whatever reason,but they're in the same boat!!

[deevel79]

Only a biased ****sucking nuthugger would vote for Calzaghe in this poll.

Had Calzaghe beat both Hopkins and Roy while at thier prime, then there would be room for debate.

[boxasmash]

Only a biased ****sucking nuthugger would vote for Calzaghe in this poll.

elaborate??

calzaghe didn't lose to two average fighters.

calzaghe has a bigger legacy of the two.

[boxasmash]

Only a biased ****sucking nuthugger would vote for Calzaghe in this poll.

Had Calzaghe beat both Hopkins and Roy while at thier prime, then there would be room for debate.

because lewis beat a prime tyson right?

jesus christ... god help people on this board.

[deevel79]

because lewis beat a prime tyson right?

jesus christ... god help people on this board.

Listen, im not even a fan of Lewis, but there's no way that Calzaghe has accomplished more than Lewis. No way!

[Underdog82]

Lewis does.

Is this post trying to bait Calzaghe fanbois or what? I am a big Calzaghe fan btw.

[Ishy Aytan]

Guys dont be surprised if you hear any guy from Setanta sports calling Calzaghe greater than Sugar Ray Robinson.

Calzaghe's the main header of Setanata boxing and you will never hear any of the guys in Setanta bad mouth him.

He's really the sole promoter of Setanta boxing. Hence dont take in too much of what guys like Mcguigan and Buncy say about him. There extremelly biased.