is calzaghe quitting a good thing or bad ?

[Edward Hitler]

is calzaghe quitting a good thing or bad for boxing ?

[tredh]

It's more of a who gives a f#ck thing.

[Pullcounter]

is calzaghe quitting a good thing or bad for boxing ?

its a good thing for boxing because calz is not interested in taking risks

[The Gully Gad]

Will we see a thousand a day threads asking him to come back ala floyd!

[Easy-E]

a good thing. we all know he wasnt looking to take on tough challenges, so smell ya later Joe.

[larryx]

to be fair the mans 37..he retired..he didnt quit

[Edward Hitler]

personally ppl say joe didnt beat elite fighters an so on and so forth and yeah he did beat up on past best fighters but who else is there in the division who could be considered elite but i agree its a good thing as im sick of seeing him beat old legends with the exception of bhop that i liked lol

[Dambala]

The good thing is that he retired with health, with a good career behind him and never exposed himself like other fighters. The bad thing is saying he's G.O.A.T. or something like that. But I really thing people should appreciate him a little bit more, he was a very very good fighter, and made the right decision retiring when he past his prime.

[Check]

Will we see a thousand a day threads asking him to come back ala floyd!

No, Joe is not as popular as Floyd. Nor is he as skilled as Floyd or has a better resume than Floyd. People don't care much for Joe Calzaghe.

[Edward Hitler]

The good thing is that he retired with health, with a good career behind him and never exposed himself like other fighters. The bad thing is saying he's G.O.A.T. or something like that. But I really thing people should appreciate him a little bit more, he was a very very good fighter, and made the right decision retiring when he past his prime.

i think what you just said is exactly spot on