3 fighters ..what number do you rank them 1-100 honestly

[FasTHarD]

Same could be said about Manny beating JMM twice.....

No, Pea was flat out ROBBED in the JCC fight.

For the record.. Pac beat Marquez and a draw... Whitaker never beat Chavez...
If you say Whitaker was robbed on that night... We can argue that Pac was robbed in the first fight since the judge admit that he scored it wrong...

[-EX-]

Dude what sport Whitaker beat Chavez?

Dude IMO Chavez is damn overrated... Check his resume and look who did he beat... 100 bums and 7 quality opponents and lost his important fights... Delahoya twice, Tszyu, draw against Whitaker.... Don't look at the numbers....

Buddy McGirt better than most names on Manny's resume
Jose Luis Ramirez
Azumah Nelson as well.

[*AKO PA HA!]

DELAHOYA,BARRERA AND MORALES ARE A.T.G.
AND PACQUIAO BEAT ALL OF THEM.
PAC BELONG TO TOP 10-20

[QuCongee]

Pac anf PBF are top 50 but Whitaker is arguably top 10

[evilp0ptart]

All things cosidered I feel Whitaker can be placed in the top 20 ATG list. I would easily rank PBF higher than Manny. Manny is the man right now and is striking while his iron is hot. Sorry but a win over Hatton right now doesn't give him that big of a boost IMO.

I agree, a Pac win over Ricky, while it would help him a lot in ATG rankings, would not boost him to the number one spot, as some seem to think. I have trouble ranking him ATG at all at this point in his career, but I can see a case for it. What would make him legendary is if he stays at welter and beats say, Cotto, or someone of that caliber. That's how you get legendary status.

I would have Whittaker somewhere in the top 30 most likely, with Floyd and Manny back somewhere around top 40-50, with Floyd being ahead at this point in their careers.

Also lol @ Pacman's resume over Whittaker's.

Oh and Larry, I'm sorry bro but I got both Barrera and Morales as ATG's, not the versions who fought Pac, but prime versions were not to be ****ed with.

[larryx]

this thread is becoming ery biased..pacman is a great fighter but not top 10 or top 20.....
nor is floyd

[Sweet Pea 50]

For the record.. Pac beat Marquez and a draw... Whitaker never beat Chavez...
If you say Whitaker was robbed on that night... We can argue that Pac was robbed in the first fight since the judge admit that he scored it wrong...

I know the first Manny-JMM fight was a draw. My point is, that both fights were close.

Pea vs JCC was not close. At all.

Hey, if you have Manny ahead of Pea, I'm not mad at you.

[larryx]

I agree, a Pac win over Ricky, while it would help him a lot in ATG rankings, would not boost him to the number one spot, as some seem to think. I have trouble ranking him ATG at all at this point in his career, but I can see a case for it. What would make him legendary is if he stays at welter and beats say, Cotto, or someone of that caliber. That's how you get legendary status.

I would have Whittaker somewhere in the top 30 most likely, with Floyd and Manny back somewhere around top 40-50, with Floyd being ahead at this point in their careers.

Also lol @ Pacman's resume over Whittaker's.

Oh and Larry, I'm sorry bro but I got both Barrera and Morales as ATG's, not the versions who fought Pac, but prime versions were not to be ****ed with.

i think i said it wrong they areat the tailend of the top 100..but that doesnt put pacman in the top 10-15

[larryx]

but this is everyone's personal opinions so i aint mad

[-EX-]

I'm done with this thread. Some of u have Pernell way too high(top 10-20 lmao). Pac over Pernell? Please. Pernell would give his ass a boxing lesson. Some of u have Floyd nowhere in site.