3 fighters ..what number do you rank them 1-100 honestly

[IMDAZED]

Why cant you understand that the Zab-Floyd fight was signed before Zab lost to Baldomir?

Because it wasn't. It was agreed upon but unless you have the documents in hand, I can't understand why you think you know what you're talking about. Hence, why Zab received only a portion of the initial offer.

Floyd is the only guy in the history of boxing to move up 5 weight classes, win 6 titles whilst remaining undefeated. If this achievement is ****, i'd like to see what a good achievement is.

I don't care about all that. Honestly. I care about who you beat and when you do it. Don't tell me about titles - especially in this age where Manny Pacquiao can move to 135, fight the weakest titlist and claim to be a six-time champ yada yada.

Floyd is definetly a top 30 ATG. This should go without saying.

That's your opinion.

Whittaker is higher than Floyd whilst Pacman is top 50.

See above.

If Pacman beats Hatton, he'll become top 30. He'll be the first guy to win 4 linear titles.

Fair enough.

Floyd is the best fighter of the 00's.

Not if what you said above happens.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

not the order..but #78???pacman at 38???thats biased

Yeah that was kind ridiculous. But by the end of this year if Pac beats Hatton and another big name, hes legacy will be unreachable by Floyds, unless he comes back and beats or atleast fights the likes of Mosley, Cotto and Pacquaio himself.

[MarksMan]

Why cant you understand that the Zab-Floyd fight was signed before Zab lost to Baldomir?

Floyd is the only guy in the history of boxing to move up 5 weight classes, win 6 titles whilst remaining undefeated. If this achievement is ****, i'd like to see what a good achievement is.

Floyd is definetly a top 30 ATG. This should go without saying.

Whittaker is higher than Floyd whilst Pacman is top 50.

If Pacman beats Hatton, he'll become top 30. He'll be the first guy to win 4 linear titles.

Floyd is the best fighter of the 00's.

Well Said!

[tredh]

Please explain by using examples of how Manny's resume is better than PBF's.

Same rules must apply to both fighters.

[larryx]

Yeah that was kind ridiculous. But by the end of this year if Pac beats Hatton and another big name, hes legacy will be unreachable by Floyds, unless he comes back and beats or atleast fights the likes of Mosley, Cotto and Pacquaio himself.

not arguing pac being ahead..but floyd is much higher than 78

[larryx]

floyd is without doubt top 30-40..pacman too

[Ishy Aytan]

Because it wasn't. It was agreed upon but unless you have the documents in hand, I can't understand why you think you know what you're talking about. Hence, why Zab received only a portion of the initial offer.


I don't care about all that. Honestly. I care about who you beat and when you do it. Don't tell me about titles - especially in this age where Manny Pacquiao can move to 135, fight the weakest titlist and claim to be a six-time champ yada yada.



That's your opinion.


See above.



Fair enough.



Not if what you said above happens.

Floyd beat the no2 guy at Supper Feather in Corrales. People can say what they want now, but pre fight, the majority of fans thought Floyd would get ko''d. Then beat Hernandez who was another highly ranked Supper Feather.

Moved up and fought a great lightweight in Castillo. Dont no where abouts he wa ranked at the time but was definetly Floyds best fight at that weight. First fight was arguebly close but he clearly won the 2nd. Castillo ent no bum, especially back in 2002. Proved it after with great wins against Corrales and Casamayor. Floyd also beat N'dou, a mandatory who had a 98% ko record. Floyd ko'd him.

Floyd went up to light welter and beat DeMarcus Corley. A good opponent coming back from a SD loss to Judah. Floyd had him down twice in the fight. Floyd fought Gatti. People can call Gatti shot but the predictions before the fight were that Floyd would win by UD or Gatti would stop him via bodyshot. This was the view of guys like Dan Rafael. Floyd dismantled Gatti.

He went on to beat Sharmba Mitchell. For obvious reasons Tszyu, Hatton and Cotto refused a fight with Floyd at Light Welter.

Floyd went on to beat Judah and Baldomir. This is Floyds weakest division, but coming up 5 weight classes ent no easy task. He should have fought Margarito and Cotto, but sadly didnt.

He moved up to Light Middle to fight Oscar, the guy he'd been chasing his whole life. Beat Oscar in his own division. Avoided Oscars left hook the whole night which i thought was incredible.

Fought an Undefeated Ricky Hatton who was a previous champ at Welter. Destroyed him 10 rounds. Fight ends in tko. Floyd prevents Hatton using his body shots the whole night.

Floyd fought some top opponents. I want him to come back and fight Pacman, hopefully Pacman beats Hatton so this fight is made possible. Margaritos out of the picture, but Floyd could still fight Mosley and Cotto, depending on whether they want a fight. But hopefully Floyd comes back to fight Pacquiao.

Floyd hasnt been p4p no1 the last 5 years fighting bums.

[IMDAZED]

Floyd beat the no2 guy at Supper Feather in Corrales. People can say what they want now, but pre fight, the majority of fans thought Floyd would get ko''d. Then beat Hernandez who was another highly ranked Supper Feather.

Moved up and fought a great lightweight in Castillo. Dont no where abouts he wa ranked at the time but was definetly Floyds best fight at that weight. First fight was arguebly close but he clearly won the 2nd. Castillo ent no bum, especially back in 2002. Proved it after with great wins against Corrales and Casamayor. Floyd also beat N'dou, a mandatory who had a 98% ko record. Floyd ko'd him.

Floyd went up to light welter and beat DeMarcus Corley. A good opponent coming back from a SD loss to Judah. Floyd had him down twice in the fight. Floyd fought Gatti. People can call Gatti shot but the predictions before the fight were that Floyd would win by UD or Gatti would stop him via bodyshot. This was the view of guys like Dan Rafael. Floyd dismantled Gatti.

He went on to beat Sharmba Mitchell. For obvious reasons Tszyu, Hatton and Cotto refused a fight with Floyd at Light Welter.

Floyd went on to beat Judah and Baldomir. This is Floyds weakest division, but coming up 5 weight classes ent no easy task. He should have fought Margarito and Cotto, but sadly didnt.

He moved up to Light Middle to fight Oscar, the guy he'd been chasing his whole life. Beat Oscar in his own division. Avoided Oscars left hook the whole night which i thought was incredible.

Fought an Undefeated Ricky Hatton who was a previous champ at Welter. Destroyed him 10 rounds. Fight ends in tko. Floyd prevents Hatton using his body shots the whole night.

Floyd fought some top opponents. I want him to come back and fight Pacman, hopefully Pacman beats Hatton so this fight is made possible. Margaritos out of the picture, but Floyd could still fight Mosley and Cotto, depending on whether they want a fight. But hopefully Floyd comes back to fight Pacquiao.

Floyd hasnt been p4p no1 the last 5 years fighting bums.

I don't disagree with anything you just said.

Sadly, it has nothing to do with anything I said.

[-EX-]

I can't belive this made 34 pgs....no offense larry.

Whitaker above Hagler lmfao. Idk if Pernell fought any1 as good as Hearns. And thatz jus one name on Hagler's resume.

[IMDAZED]

I can't belive this made 34 pgs....no offense larry.

Whitaker above Hagler lmfao. Idk if Pernell fought any1 as good as Hearns. And thatz jus one name on Hagler's resume.

You'd rate Hearns ahead of Chavez???