3 fighters ..what number do you rank them 1-100 honestly

[QuCongee]

LOL.

But seriously, saying Hagler is the greatest MW of all-time doesn't make him higher than Whitaker.

Oh I did'nt say he ranks higher than Whitaker but those 2 guys should never be more than a few names apart, on any list.

[FasTHarD]

that was not the same oscar.......

That's the Oscar i know but just can't pull the trigger...

[DarchinyFAN]

I generally try and stay away from ranking current or recent fighters in all time lists. Really need a few years to see how their careers and the careers of their top opponents play out. Also, it takes a few years for your emotions to subside and take a real critical look at what they did.

Whitaker 30-50
(around 30 is definently my cieling on him, the floor might actually be slightly higher than 50, but I could be convinced anywhere in that range)

Pacquiao 20-40
(This is alittle bit on speculation especially in the case of the cieling, because if I made a alltime p4p list this moment he certainly wouldnt be #20, that win against Hatton would certainly help.)

Mayweather 50-70

[Dynamite Kid]

I'm not sayin Marvin's top 10 but Pernell sure as hell aint. He lost to Leonard who shoe-shined his ass off and Marvin wasn't in his prime anymore. He beat Mugabi end of story. And Duran would tear Pernell apart.

Niether was Leonard.

I dont think he would. Duran could not handle lateral movement. Chavez and Nelson were just as ferocious as Duran and they could not pin Whitaker down.

[IMDAZED]

Oh I did'nt say he ranks higher than Whitaker but those 2 guys should never be more than a few names apart, on any list.

Agreed 100%.

I'm tired of talking to these newbies, man. It's frustrating. If I have to break down Pea's resume, I have to break down Chavez's, then Nelson's yada yada.

[-EX-]

I'm done. This is crazy. Pernell top 10? Thatz bull****. Freakin hilarious. 20-30 you can make an argument. How da hell is Pernell higher than Joe Frazier, and Marvin Hagler. Hagler had 13 or 14 str8 title defenses.

[Sweet Pea 50]

I'm not sayin Marvin's top 10 but Pernell sure as hell aint. He lost to Leonard who shoe-shined his ass off and Marvin wasn't in his prime anymore. He beat Mugabi end of story. And Duran would tear Pernell apart.

Hyperbole........

[IMDAZED]

I'm done. This is crazy. Pernell top 10? Thatz bull****. Freakin hilarious. 20-30 you can make an argument. How da hell is Pernell higher than Joe Frazier, and Marvin Hagler. Hagler had 13 or 14 str8 title defenses.

Hagler having 13-14 straight defenses doesn't make him higher.

Pernell had 10 defenses at 135 (not including non-title bouts), and unified. In higher divisions he beat McGirt, Chavez, Vasquez, and on and on and on.

Sigh...

[UnDeniable]

Is this based on how good they are/were or their standings in history

Skills

1. Floyd
2. Pea





3. Pacquiao


Overall accomplishments

1. Pea
2. Pacquiao
3. Floyd

[Burner]

burner dont come in here with that biased ****...you'll get floyd bashed

Floyd is top 10.....Love him or hate him hes unbeatable....point blank.

Sweet Pea definetly top 50.

And Pacman is in the 50-60 range.