Zab Judah vs. Carlos Quintana is Being Discussed

[GRUSTLER]

HBO thinks we are idiots as boxing fans. Yes, I will watch the Judah Vs Quitana fight ,but for the outcome to be the winner fights Berto for a title is pure ignorance on HBO and Lou Dibella part. Berto for some reason is to become a prodigy for HBO. He shouldn't even be a title holder as it was won against Mikki Rodriguez after Mayweather Jr. retired. Then the very controversial ,but exciting fight against Collazo who in my opinion won. Now he gets a fight against possibly one of two guys who should be climbing there way back to a title shot in the next year or so. Clottey or Collazo should be the sure fire canidates at this point for Berto. Hell I think Berto still needs more improvement in some areas of his game before he is truly a champion. I believe he is fully capable of doing that on his own without the help of corporate influence. How can he prove to be the best without fighting the best. Props to Cotto, Williams, Mosley, Clottey, and those who make boxing a memorable exprience for the fans even Margarito who is innocent.

I agree. Seems like HBO has Andre Berto on a pedestal right now like he is so great but in actuality dude needs some real improvement & cannot hang with any of the big boys at 147. Sounds to me like their trying to get the most out of Berto name & likability while it last. Putting him in the ring with Joshua Clottey would get him creamed so why not put him in with Zab Judah or Carlos Quintana? Two guys that Berto may have a chance with. The way Berto fights I am not even sure that he can beat Judah because Judah comes on strong in the first 4rds & Collazo clocked Berto in the 1st Rd sending him back with the left in a South Paw stance.

Judah is a South Paw who is quicker & stronger than Collazo. The only thing I can say is that Berto's determination & heart is more impressive than Judah's at this point. As far as Carlos Quintana goes, I just feel like he is the more seasoned then both of them & had KO'd someone at catch weight 152 so he is a risk for Judah & Berto. If Dibella was smart & wanted to get Berto a potential win, they would just put him in there with Judah but they definitely need to stop hiding this kid or have him give up the belt.

[MaFu MoFo]

Judah should follow PBF and retire, period.

[KingTito]

Judah should campaign at 140. He can't compete with the top dogs at 147. I'm not saying Quintana is at the elite at 147, but he's damn good and would beat Quintana IMO.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Judah should campaign at 140. He can't compete with the top dogs at 147. I'm not saying Quintana is at the elite at 147, but he's damn good and would beat Quintana IMO.

Quintana vs Quintana???????????

[a-raines21]

Quintana vs Quintana???????????

quintana sucks....... zab fell off..... theres no point in this fight.....

[KJB]

That would be a fun fight.
Looks like they are still doing a good job of keeping Berto's 0.

[KJB]

Zab Judah is the best 6-round welterweight fighter in the world,

He used to be, I he didnt look like it in his fights post Cotto. This really is a last chance type of deal for Judah, he is coming dangerously close to Chop Chop territory.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

quintana sucks....... zab fell off..... theres no point in this fight.....

They dont suck. Zab is just a underachiever, and Quintana is just a better fighter than Judah as of now!!!!!!!

[KESSLER]

They dont suck. Zab is just a underachiever, and Quintana is just a better fighter than Judah as of now!!!!!!!

I agree bro. Quintana beats Judah.

[DuttyAlacrity]

Sound good I'd watch that