..If Hatton Beats Pacquiao, He's Not Number One...

[hotshoes]

if he does win hhis rank will increase depending upon the manner of his win

[BetterCallSaul]

Bull****. Hatton has Malignaggi and PERHAPS Pacquiao recently. Marquez has Juarez (counters Malignaggi) and Casamayor and a close one with Pacquiao (counters JUST beating Pacquiao, since I doubt he beats Manny devastatingly.) Marquez still gets the nod over Hatton. Just the facts.

The Juarez who lost twice to Barrera in 2006?

Mallignaggi is just as good a win as Casamayor. Casa was losing his last fight with Katsidis until he got the KO.

And a defeat to Pacquaio comes no way near actually beating him.

[THe TRiNiTY]

The Juarez who lost twice to Barrera in 2006?

Mallignaggi is just as good a win as Casamayor. Casa was losing his last fight with Katsidis until he got the KO.

And a defeat to Pacquaio comes no way near actually beating him.

But the press make up the p4p rankings. And the press ALMOST ALL SAY Marquez won the second fight. For the record, losing a fight isn't at all like having lost the fight. Casamayor won the fight, so he was still a relatively live fighter.

The Casamayor that Marquez beat >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Malignaggi at any stage of his career.

[BetterCallSaul]

But the press make up the p4p rankings. And the press ALMOST ALL SAY Marquez won the second fight. For the record, losing a fight isn't at all like having lost the fight. Casamayor won the fight, so he was still a relatively live fighter.

The Casamayor that Marquez beat >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Malignaggi at any stage of his career.

Just a shame the press didn't judge the fight then. He officially lost both fights.

The Casamayor that Marquez beat just came out of a war with Katsidis, and is 37 years old. Mallignaggi was in his prime, and Hatton beat him with ease. But Mallignaggi can't punch, so that makes the wins about equal.

[THe TRiNiTY]

Just a shame the press didn't judge the fight then. He officially lost both fights.

The Casamayor that Marquez beat just came out of a war with Katsidis, and is 37 years old. Mallignaggi was in his prime, and Hatton beat him with ease. But Mallignaggi can't punch, so that makes the wins about equal.

Actually, he only OFFICIALLY lost ONE of those fights.

Malignaggi has looked **** for his last three fights, can't punch and has NEVER been a great fighter.

Casamayor is a better fighter, even now. If Casamayor moved up, I'd pick him to beat Paulie, no joke.

[BetterCallSaul]

Actually, he only OFFICIALLY lost ONE of those fights.

Malignaggi has looked **** for his last three fights, can't punch and has NEVER been a great fighter.

Casamayor is a better fighter, even now. If Casamayor moved up, I'd pick him to beat Paulie, no joke.

Oh yeah a draw.

I probably would, but not in the manner Hatton beat him.

[Mr. Philadel]

if Hatton wins he'll jump up on the list.....but no way he becomes top dog......Joe Calzaghe would be the next logical choice.......Marquez wouldn't look right bein' the top dog if Ricky beats the guy who beat him twice

[THe TRiNiTY]

Oh yeah a draw.

I probably would, but not in the manner Hatton beat him.

Yeah, he might not knock him out, but he'd probably have an easy go of it.

[THe TRiNiTY]

if Hatton wins he'll jump up on the list.....but no way he becomes top dog......Joe Calzaghe would be the next logical choice.......Marquez wouldn't look right bein' the top dog if Ricky beats the guy who beat him twice

However, the press makes up the p4p list. And virtually everyone in the press thinks that Marquez won the second fight. It wouldn't seem like a jump or anything to put him in the 1 spot.

[Miburo]

He would need more than that to become number one. If he managed to take out, for example, Pacquiao and Mayweather, then there'd be a definite argument.