Fighter of the decade

[-----------]

What title was calzaghe defending against Hopkins?

hmm, where did I state they were Calzaghe's defences?

[-EX-]

against who might i ask??

do wins over guys like lacy, bika, hopkins (disputed), washed up RJJ, and kessler compare to guys like floyd and manny who have beaten people like morales,barerra, hernandez, judah, de la hoya, hatton, marquez, castillo, corrales etc.....

I think he was joking...

[KostyaTszyu44]

They wern't all fighting for a World title



And Omar Sheika, Richie Woodhall, Charles Brewer, Byron Mitchell, Jeff Lacy, Sakio Bika, Peter Manfredo Jr, Mikkel Kessler, Bernard Hopkins and Roy Jones Jr.

whoa ho ho!! thats a bonafide list of HoFers right there!

hopkins is the only great fighter on that list (RJJ was garbage when calzaghe beat him) and hop was past his prime anyway

[-----------]

against who might i ask??

do wins over guys like lacy, bika, hopkins (disputed), washed up RJJ, and kessler compare to guys like floyd and manny who have beaten people like morales,barerra, hernandez, judah, de la hoya, hatton, marquez, castillo, corrales etc.....

whats this, a 2 on 1 argument.

state one or the other chump.

[javelin_fangs]

where is lennox? he was the last great heavyweight who defeated all there was to defeat.

Are you kidding me? Lennox did not fight beyond 2003. Get the fu(k out of here with that.

[-----------]

Lmao, I made the first post on this thread as a JOKE.

But the responses have been so ******ED I just have to defend Calzaghe here.

[Technical_Skill]

hmm, where did I state they were Calzaghe's defences?

Here.

I didnt know defenses against the likes of Kabery Salem, Tocker Pudwill, and will mcintyre made you the fighter of the decade.

And Omar Sheika, Richie Woodhall, Charles Brewer, Byron Mitchell, Jeff Lacy, Sakio Bika, Peter Manfredo Jr, Mikkel Kessler, Bernard Hopkins and Roy Jones Jr.

[-----------]

Here.

so you stated it, and i made a mistake of misreading and quoting it.

So right,to get a Fighter of the Decade only defences of a title count.

Right, Calzaghe still gets it.

[klipsch speaker]

Are you kidding me? Lennox did not fight beyond 2003. Get the fu(k out of here with that.

ok, ok. but those are still within the decade right? and they were all against quality opponents. ok, what about the exclusion of barrera? he has two victories against morales, one against ayala ( a RING fighter of the year), kelley, tapia and robbie peden (for a junior lightweight title )...

[The_Italian]

its somewhere between hopkins and mayweather.