would floyd beat the shane that fought margarito yesterday?

[boxasmash]

he looked so fast, so fit, like the mosley of old. could floyd beat that? floyd hasnt fought anyone near mosley's class.

[Left Hook Tua]

i don't know but prime for prime at 135-154......shane beats floyd.

[MindBat]

"Definitely!"

[IMG]http://i218.***********.com/albums/cc316/assaulthill/lennox_lewis_482x246.jpg[/IMG]

[mrpain81]

i don't know but prime for prime at 135-154......shane beats floyd.

I always thought so.

[dajabgameisill]

shane loses to people who are slick boxers ...


floyd

winky wright ...


he beats everyone who just fights in front of him ...


so yea...floyd would probably win a UD- or SD ...


but i still want to see it ...


i dont think shane would lose any credibility even if he lost ...shane is at the end of his career ....if they would have fought in shanes prime he would have destroyed floyd ...no problem

[Left Hook Tua]

I always thought so.

shane has the power advantage.

shane's hand are pretty fast.

shane has a very good chin.

shane has a heart and tough as nails.

floyd fights very slow guys especially above 135 which enhances people's view on his speed and skills.

shane is no arturo gatti or carlos baldomir.

[MindBat]

shane loses to people who are slick boxers ...


floyd

winky wright ...


he beats everyone who just fights in front of him ...


so yea...floyd would probably win a UD- or SD ...


but i still want to see it ...


i dont think shane would lose any credibility even if he lost ...shane is at the end of his career ....if they would have fought in shanes prime he would have destroyed floyd ...no problem

Good answer. But, have to disagree with him beating Floyd earlier in his career.

Floyd chased Mosley before giving up on fighting him at all.

[Silencers]

Yes, I think he would have.

[Left Hook Tua]

shane loses to people who are slick boxers ...


floyd

winky wright ...


he beats everyone who just fights in front of him ...


so yea...floyd would probably win a UD- or SD ...


but i still want to see it ...


i dont think shane would lose any credibility even if he lost ...shane is at the end of his career ....if they would have fought in shanes prime he would have destroyed floyd ...no problem

who are the slick boxers shane lost too?

what bothers shane is length.

forrest is very tall and long. winky while not that tall is also long.

[dajabgameisill]

Good answer. But, have to disagree with him beating Floyd earlier in his career.

Floyd chased Mosley before giving up on fighting him at all.

well sometimes it doesnt make sense because the money isnt right... i mean honestly ...when did floyd really make a name for himself??? probably after the delahoya fight? before that ... he was a nobody... if floyd would have fought shane at 135 in his prime... when shane was super fast and super strong ??? he would have walk through floyd mayweather...