The test of greatness!!!

[badboypeenoy]

I wanted to pit two great fighters against each other. To do this I have developed a fair system for scoring each fighters respective wins.

1 star fights will earn 1pt for a win
2 star fights will earn 2pts for a win
3 star fights will earn 3pts for a win

Any loss will mean -3pts

Draws and no contests will earn 0 pts

In my scoring system I have pitched two great fighters against each other. Hopkins and Calzaghe. I have tried to be as unbiased as possible and believe I have put each fighters opponents in the right classing system. But as always, it will be highly based on opinion.


Hopkins

Hopkins - Fights before world level = 23

22 Wins
1 Defeat

23pts - 3pts = 20pts

1 star fights - Richie, Hall, Wynn, Aquino, Mercado (2nd fight), Frank, Council, Brown, Allen (NC), Allen, Hakkar, Allen

11 Wins
1 No contest

11pts - 0pt = 11pts

2 star fights - Mercado(D), Lipsey, James, Jackson, Echolls, Vanderpool, Echolls, Holmes, Daniels, Joppy, Eastman,

10 Wins
1 Draw

20pts - 0pts = 20pts

3 star fights - Jones(Loss), Johnson, Trinidad, De La Hoya, Taylor(Loss), Taylor(Loss), Tarver, Wright, Calzaghe(Loss), Pavlik

6 Wins
4 Losses

18pts - 12pts = 6pts

Hopkins Overall Points = 57

Calzaghe

Calzaghe fights before world level = 22

22 Wins

22pts - 0pts = 22pts

1 star fights - Sobot, Ferreya, Thornberry, Starie, Woodhall, Veit, Mcintyre, Jiminez, Pudwill, Mkrtchian, Salem, Veit , Manfredo, Jones

14 Wins

14pts - 0pts = 14pts

2 star fights - Reid, Sheika, Brewer, Mitchell, Ashira, Lacy, Bika

7 Wins

14pts - 0pts = 14pts

3 star fights - Eubank, Kessler, Hopkins

3 Wins

9pts - 0pts = 9pts

Calzaghe Overall Points = 59

Hopkins Overall Points = 57

Calzaghe wins by split decison.

This is precisely how boxrec works...hence this is crap.

[KostyaTszyu44]

I wanted to pit two great fighters against each other. To do this I have developed a fair system for scoring each fighters respective wins.

1 star fights will earn 1pt for a win
2 star fights will earn 2pts for a win
3 star fights will earn 3pts for a win

Any loss will mean -3pts

Draws and no contests will earn 0 pts

In my scoring system I have pitched two great fighters against each other. Hopkins and Calzaghe. I have tried to be as unbiased as possible and believe I have put each fighters opponents in the right classing system. But as always, it will be highly based on opinion.


Hopkins

Hopkins - Fights before world level = 23

22 Wins
1 Defeat

23pts - 3pts = 20pts

1 star fights - Richie, Hall, Wynn, Aquino, Mercado (2nd fight), Frank, Council, Brown, Allen (NC), Allen, Hakkar, Allen

11 Wins
1 No contest

11pts - 0pt = 11pts

2 star fights - Mercado(D), Lipsey, James, Jackson, Echolls, Vanderpool, Echolls, Holmes, Daniels, Joppy, Eastman,

10 Wins
1 Draw

20pts - 0pts = 20pts

3 star fights - Jones(Loss), Johnson, Trinidad, De La Hoya, Taylor(Loss), Taylor(Loss), Tarver, Wright, Calzaghe(Loss), Pavlik

6 Wins
4 Losses

18pts - 12pts = 6pts

Hopkins Overall Points = 57

Calzaghe

Calzaghe fights before world level = 22

22 Wins

22pts - 0pts = 22pts

1 star fights - Sobot, Ferreya, Thornberry, Starie, Woodhall, Veit, Mcintyre, Jiminez, Pudwill, Mkrtchian, Salem, Veit , Manfredo, Jones

14 Wins

14pts - 0pts = 14pts

2 star fights - Reid, Sheika, Brewer, Mitchell, Ashira, Lacy, Bika

7 Wins

14pts - 0pts = 14pts

3 star fights - Eubank, Kessler, Hopkins

3 Wins

9pts - 0pts = 9pts

Calzaghe Overall Points = 59

Hopkins Overall Points = 57

Calzaghe wins by split decison.

calzaghe a better fighter than hopkins???

both your mind and your ranking system is ****ed up

[nathan_nall]

calzaghe a better fighter than hopkins???

both your mind and your ranking system is ****ed up

He could be totally wrong, but the WHOLE POINT to the thread is... he's trying to come to a decision based upon something measureable... not just his personal oppinion.

Would you still feel that way if it found Bernard to be the better fighter?

[Brother Naazim]

Guys, lay the fuck off. Here you have a poster doing something genuinely original, and you're just ****ting all over him because you don't like the results.

Personally, I think the system is a little bit flawed, but I'm loving the idea. And you forgot Jones on Calzaghe's list of opponets.