They have Calzaghe as ATG but not Mosley? WTF?

[daggum]

Calzaghe is definately an alltime great...However we'll never know to what extent because it took so long for him to secure high profile fights...I've always liked Calzaghe as a fighter dating all the way back to his many fights on Showtime...Whats unfortunate is that he never secured a bigtime fight with any of the name fighters in and around his weightclass while all parties were in their respective primes i.e. Hopkins, Jones ect...

you are right we will never know. saying someone is an all time great based upon what they might have done. that's a first.

[daggum]

err...........46-0

your hero has the same undefeated untested record as sven ottke and zsolt erdei. WONDERFUL COMPANY!

[IMDAZED]

you are right we will never know. saying someone is an all time great based upon what they might have done. that's a first.

Not on these boards.

"Calzaghe would've beaten (insert ATG here) if only (insert excuse for fight not happening here)."

[hammerhiem]

Calzaghe is definately an alltime great...However we'll never know to what extent because it took so long for him to secure high profile fights...I've always liked Calzaghe as a fighter dating all the way back to his many fights on Showtime...Whats unfortunate is that he never secured a bigtime fight with any of the name fighters in and around his weightclass while all parties were in their respective primes i.e. Hopkins, Jones ect...

Well done for breaking the Low IQ barrier on teh calzaghe side, as if having ****** people on the hater side wasn't enough.

[catalinul]

Neither Calzaghe or Mosley are ATGs.They are HOFers though.

[daggum]

Not on these boards.

"Calzaghe would've beaten (insert ATG here) if only (insert excuse for fight not happening here)."

calzaghe would've beaten sugar ray robinson if only he didn't duck him by being no longer alive.

[Kid McCoy]

Not on these boards.

"Calzaghe would've beaten (insert ATG here) if only (insert excuse for fight not happening here)."

Isn't that what everyone says about guys Roy Jones and Floyd Mayweather should have met but didn't?

[IMDAZED]

Isn't that what everyone says about guys Roy Jones and Floyd Mayweather should have met but didn't?

True. Thankfully, they beat some prime pound for pounders at their peak as well so we don't have to speculate on that.

[hammerhiem]

calzaghe would've beaten sugar ray robinson if only he didn't duck him by being no longer alive.

WHAT, SRR could have come back, he didn't die until 89!

Joe was an Amature then, SRR was clearly scared.

[Roger Mellie]

Isn't that what everyone says about guys Roy Jones and Floyd Mayweather should have met but didn't?

you seem to have missed out hopkins and toney lmao