If Shane beats Tony, will he rank above Oscar and Tito on the All-Time list?

[El Chicano]

He's already there. Shane has never been stopped and always took on the toughest guys out there. DLH and Tito have been embarrassed before.

Winky beat Tito worse in ONE fight than he beat Shane in two fights.

[Caxcan]

well he'd definitely rank among the best steroid using champions of all time

[El Chicano]

well he'd definitely rank among the best steroid using champions of all time

LOL, and Tito would rank among the best cast wrapping champs, while Oscar would rank among the best ****** dressing champs.

[KiloTeague]

Someone said that Benard called him out for his hand wraps and he stopped knocking people out. Well after tito fought Bernard he KO haceine cheriffi, then KO Carlos Myorga, then lost to Winky.

Give me a break hater, you spout out bs thats not true and ignore the fact that Tito has only lost to Winky, Bernard, and Roy Jones. All defensive specialists who were bigger. These were the only guys from this era that could beat Tito and he fought and beat everyone else anyway.

Tito is a hall of famer who got beat by two all time greats and a hall of famer. Thats not bad. Its a better looking resume than either Oscar or Shane.

Do I have to start calling you guys out on everthing you say?

Common keep it real.

[Dambala]

A Margarito defeat does nothing that big for Shane, it would be a great achievement based on his age but not for his legacy as an ATG or something like that I really respect Margarito but he would've been beaten by most of the welters of the Trinidad-DeLaHoya era.

[El Chicano]

A Margarito defeat does nothing that big for Shane, it would be a great achievement based on his age but not for his legacy as an ATG or something like that I really respect Margarito but he would've been beaten by most of the welters of the Trinidad-DeLaHoya era.

Which Welters do you speak of???

[DarchinyFAN]

No Shane doesnt have the list of opponents the other 2 had.
It will definently bring him closer though.

[niceguy45]

not.....mosley would have to beat margarito and then rematch cotto;
and then he might be up there

[mickyward5656]

If shane beats tony he would easly he higher than tito even though i loved tito. him and de la hoya would be close but i still give it to de la hoya even thought he officially lost to him twice(i believe he oscar won the second fight). i believe oscar beat tito easy despite what the judges said, and mosley in his prime would easly beat a prime tito. this from a tito fan....

[larryx]

mosley beat oscar 2 times..i think he's already ranked higher