Whats up with judges????????

[Bushbaby]

I get frustrated sometimes with how judges see fights,here are 2 fights I will use as my examples,hopefully u all can notice my comparisons!!De La Hoya-Mayweather,Cory Spinks-Jermain Taylor!!They were almost identical in way of performance,Mayweather fought defensively,and boxed using the ring and running "no offence",to a victory,about a week after,Spinks did the same thing and the judges gave the fight to Taylor,stating that he was the aggressor and deserved the win,what can be done to get more consistent decisions???????

[-MAKAVELLI-]

im still waiting for anyone to breakdown the 116-111 score for berto

[ИATAS]

there definitely needs to be more consistency with scoring. I don't know how to accomplish that, maybe more thorough training on how to actually score fights.

With that said keep in mind judges don't have the luxury of instant replays and great camera views. They are sitting on one side of the ring and don't always see exactly what we see.

[Scott9945]

I get frustrated sometimes with how judges see fights,here are 2 fights I will use as my examples,hopefully u all can notice my comparisons!!De La Hoya-Mayweather,Cory Spinks-Jermain Taylor!!They were almost identical in way of performance,Mayweather fought defensively,and boxed using the ring and running "no offence",to a victory,about a week after,Spinks did the same thing and the judges gave the fight to Taylor,stating that he was the aggressor and deserved the win,what can be done to get more consistent decisions???????

I don't see any comparison in those two fights. Both times the right fighter got his hand raised.

[larryx]

spinks-taylor-pbf-oscar-were to completly differant fights..how can you say floyd had 0 offense when he landed more punches than oscar....ans taylor outlanded spinks who did nothing

[S.G.]

sometimes i know i could do a better, more objective job than some of these guys... and i'm hardly a veteran or the most knowledgable person on boxing amongst knowledgable people......... there must be better candidates out there than alot of the guys we have now


oh and also, this:

spinks-taylor-pbf-oscar-were to completly differant fights..how can you say floyd had 0 offense when he landed more punches than oscar....ans taylor outlanded spinks who did nothing

[catalinul]

As boring as Spinks is,he should be robbed every fight.

[S.G.]

With that said keep in mind judges don't have the luxury of instant replays and great camera views. They are sitting on one side of the ring and don't always see exactly what we see.

i was under the impression they had TV screens to watch it now... like commentator's do

if not, then they definitely should, imo

[larryx]

sometimes i know i could do a better, more objective job than some of these guys... and i'm hardly a veteran or the most knowledgable person on boxing amongst knowledgable people......... there must be better candidates out there than alot of the guys we have now


oh and also, this:

so r u agreeing with me????

[S.G.]

so r u agreeing with me????

...yeah.......