why do some people question Kessler's resume?

[Zocalo]

Well because it is questionable... people question Calzaghes... why should Kessler be exempt?

[Guest]

Harding was coming off wins over Daniel Judah and David Telesco.

Ring Magazine rankings at the end of 2005:

Antonio Tarver, Champion

1. Glen Johnson
2. Zsolt Erdei
3. Roy Jones Jr.
4. Clinton Woods
5. Fabrice Tiozzo
6. Tomasz Adamek
7. Julio Cesar Gonzalez
8. Paul Briggs
9. Hugo Hernan Garay
10. Eric Harding

http://www.boxrec.com/media/index.ph...yweight--2000s

The Adamek win is looking really good at this point looking at this. and it was a good win. Dawson's resume is fine and only going to get better.

[boxasmash]

kessler and dawson both have good resumes at this stage.

[Flawless.]

Well maybe becasue Mundine is his best win

[Flawless.]

Well maybe becasue Mundine is his best win

Damn I need to get my facts straight. His best win is his loss to Calzaghe.

[Mr. Philadel]

Nice research.

Can you do it for Chad Dawson as well? Would be fun to compare.

I 2nd that

[boxasmash]

Damn I need to get my facts straight. His best win is his loss to Calzaghe.

what is zab judah's best win?

[Flawless.]

what is zab judah's best win?

His win over Cory Spinks still better than Bumdine

[boxasmash]

I 2nd that

Chad dawson has fought 3 top 10 light heavyweights since he debuted at 175 in 2006.

antonio tarver, tomasz ademek and glen johnson. none of the three was the #1 of the division like calzaghe was for kessler but it's still pretty decent.

[CiganoBoxer]

he fought everyone he had to fight, just because of 2 blips on his resume (last two fights) everyone questions his resume. it seems your only as good as your last fight on this forum.

since his debut in the smw division in 2001 the top 10 looked like this.

1.Sven Ottke
2.Joe Calzaghe
3.Byron Mitchell
4.Antwun Echols
5.Charles Brewer
6.Thomas Tate
7.Eric Lucas
8.Mads Larsen
9.Manny Siaca
10.Markus Beyer

in 2002 it looks like this

1.Joe Calzaghe
2.Sven Ottke
3.Antwun Echols
4.Eric Lucas
5.Byron Mitchell
6.Charles Brewer
7.Mads Larsen
8.Manny Siaca
9.Anthony Mundine
10.Markus Beyer

in 2003 it looks like this

1.Joe Calzaghe
2.Sven Ottke
3.Anthony Mundine
4.Antwun Echols
5.Danny Green
6.Byron Mitchell
7.Markus Beyer
8.Charles Brewer
9.Mads Larsen
10.Robin Reid

in 2004 Kessler enters the list

1.Joe Calzaghe
2.Mikkel Kessler
3.Anthony Mundine
4.Antwun Echols
5.Danny Green
6.Jeff Lacy
7.Mads Larsen
8.Robin Reid
9.Markus Beyer
10.Manny Siaca

in 2005 it looked like this after beating mundine

1.Joe Calzaghe
2.Mikkel Kessler
3.Jeff Lacy
4.Markus Beyer
5.Anthony Mundine
6.Danny Green
7.Manny Siaca
8.Otis Grant
9.Robin Reid
10.Librado Andrade

in 2006 it looked like this, kessler fought beyer and andrade

Joe Calzaghe, Champion

1.Mikkel Kessler
2.Anthony Mundine
3.Jeff Lacy
4.Markus Beyer
5.Librado Andrade
6.Lucian Bute
7.Carl Froch
8.Allan Green
9.Denis Inkin
10.Peter Manfredo Jr.


RED = EVENTUALLY FOUGHT THEM OR FOUGHT ALREADY
BLACK = FOUGHT THEM THAT YEAR


He basically fought everyone he had to, get off his back!

God that post puts Calzaghes title run in to persecutive