Roy Jone Jr. (G.O.AT 160,168,175)

[Silencers]

Jones is not the greatest at any of those weights.

I agree with this.

[WLAD_OWNS]

175 - Gene Tunney
168 - Joe Calzaghe
160 - Sugar Ray Robinson

[MANGLER]

He's got a sick legacy at 175, but even there he ain't the GOAT.

[THE REED]

legacy wise no... but straight up in a boxing ring.. just who wins? roy gives them all a run for them money between 160-175... and IMO and a lot of others nobody beats him at 168.. including joseph.

[shynequasiog22]

legacy wise no... but straight up in a boxing ring.. just who wins? roy gives them all a run for them money between 160-175... and IMO and a lot of others nobody beats him at 168.. including joseph.

I think this is what the starter is implying. Legacy wise Roy isn't in the conversation at 160 or 168 because he didn't fight long enough at those weights. At 175 he is more in the conversation but the best is pushing it. However like Reed said in his prime at those weights is where the argument is, and I don't think I would pick anybody over him.

[dde91]

Hopkins has a legendary reign at middleweight

against Welterweights and nobodies

sickening

so his 20+ defenses where against Welterweights? There were only two welterweights. And Tito had his power from WW to MW. He knocked out Joppy. And Joppy has a legit Chin, and he was champion. Most people thought Tito would knock out Hopkins.

Jones fought a FAT OUT OF SHAPE RETIRED TITO, and nobody talks about that.

[Enemy/Friend]

so his 20+ defenses where against Welterweights? There were only two welterweights. And Tito had his power from WW to MW. He knocked out Joppy. And Joppy has a legit Chin, and he was champion. Most people thought Tito would knock out Hopkins.

Jones fought a FAT OUT OF SHAPE RETIRED TITO, and nobody talks about that.

You took the bait

[KiloTeague]

Roy was unbeatable and dominating for fifteen years. Find me anothe fighte with that and I'll give you it.

[daggum]

I would like to see Roy Jones fight Bob Foster, Michael Spinks, Ezzard Charles, Archie Moore at 175 lbs...

come on now man he's not gonna stoop that low to fight those old guys. calzaghe on the other hand...........

[Enemy/Friend]

come on now man he's not gonna stoop that low to fight those guys. calzaghe on the other hand...........

Daggum why do you hate Calzaghe so much? Serious question......