In which fight WINKY was robbed??????

[aljosa_raos]

IN HOPKINS,TAYLOR or VARGAS fight??
I think he won Vargas and Taylor fight but Hopkins didnt do anything against WRIGHT except few counters and hold all the time.I thnk WINKY won Hopkins 8-4 rounds or 9-3.
Whats you opinion?

[deliveryman]

I thought Winky won the Taylor fight.
I thought Vargas edged it
And I thought Winky got his ass handed to him by BHOP.

[savorduhflavor]

I thought Winky beat Vargas and Taylor, but lost to Hopkins.

[roujinziro]

I never saw the Vargas or BHop fight, but I thought he was clearly robbed against Taylor. Taylor would just put up his guard when he got cornered and not throw punches, not the best way to win rounds, but nothing solves that like some good 'ol home-cookin' from the judges.

[aljosa_raos]

Winky hit Hopkins more in that fight.He was more agresive.He got headbuted.
Judges give rounds to B-Hop based on demolition of Tarver in my opinion.
Winky gassed in 11 and 12 but he won the fight.He looked better then Calzaghe.

[K-Nan]

He lost the Taylor fight.. It was close enough to have hinged on that last round. He lost the Vargas fight a lot clearer than would be expected if you just listened to the shouts of robbery. And he clearly, decisively lost to Hopkins.

[deliveryman]

Winky hit Hopkins more in that fight.He was more agresive.He got headbuted.
Judges give rounds to B-Hop based on demolition of Tarver in my opinion.
Winky gassed in 11 and 12 but he won the fight.He looked better then Calzaghe.

The fight wasn't even that close. Bernard won comfortably.

[Bushbaby]

Winky should not have foughB-hop at 170,he would have won at 160.He did win the Taylor fight and against Vargas,he was robbed,Vargas only had a big 12th round!!

[warp1432]

I thought he edged both Taylor and Vargas, but clearly lost to Hopkins.

[Steak]

I had him winning all 3, actually.

none were robberies though.