Who is more overrated?

[KostyaTszyu44]

I voted for Taylor, he is the weakest fighter on that list.

lol so froch is a better fighter than taylor then............

[Kastrioti]

No I didn't say that.. But in Taylor's case.. remember this thread is about people being overrated.. and If Taylor has earned respect on a Loss, then something is wrong.. I mean if on his best night.. when it all seemed to come together and he finally showed some heart.. and the best he could could come up with was a loss.. Then why would that earn him respect?? all those gift decisions and fights against welter weights can't be erased by a losing effort.. That would be illogical..

Dude, people say "gift decision" and completely rid the fighter of any credit for that fight. Maybe the B-Hop and the Winky fight were gifts, maybe they weren't, but just the fact that Taylor can hang with guys of that caliber shows enough. Pavlik beat him, and he would beat him again if they fought, It's just a bad style for Taylor. What have people said about Taylor that makes him so overrated? What I've heard so far is that he's the best SMW, which I don't agree with, I think Kessler is, but it's still open for debate, Kessler would not in any way dominate Taylor, Taylor is definitely the second best SMW.

[WLAD_OWNS]

lol so froch is a better fighter than taylor then............

If the one dimensional Pavlik can beat Taylor twice.....so can Froch

Froch by late TKO

[Kastrioti]

I think Dawson is the most overrated one in that list, he's very good, but people are going around saying that guys like B-Hop and Calzaghe are afraid and ducking Dawson.....

[Welter_Skelter]

lol so froch is a better fighter than taylor then............

That is not the question here.. the question is who is more overrated.. and Froch is very underrated wouldn't you say??.. no one seems to like him.. so his overrating shouldn't even be in question at this time..

Taylor on the other Hand, has stunk for years.. and people still jerk his balls every chance they get.. THAT is the definition of overrated..

[WLAD_OWNS]

Taylor needs to stop ducking Froch!

[Trim0]

I think Dawson is the most overrated one in that list, he's very good, but people are going around saying that guys like B-Hop and Calzaghe are afraid and ducking Dawson.....

yeah dawson sucks ass
most overrated champ of all time
who has he beat? a 50 year old Johnson? give me a break!