Who has the better Resume? Julio Cesar Chavez or Hector Camacho Sr.?

[El Dominicano]

Gonna have to go with JCC

[larryx]

chavez..resume=who you beat not who you fought..or journey men would have the best resumes

[DarchinyFAN]

Yes ...just meant who he fought....Winning a fight can easily be challenged by us fans (but don't want to get into that)...Chavez with Whitaker and Meldrick Taylor Etc....Camacho with Rosario and Duran.....Some fans can say the other guys won too...Face it if you guys followed both of their careers....They both had some controversial wins (like I said dont want to get into that). Also a "resume" Does not necessarily mean who they beat....a resume shows your experience.

I can pick a gatekeeper type, that every good fighter in the weight divisions around him fought on their way up in an era, and say hey look at that awsome resume.

[Chups]

Good question. Chavez lost the big fights tho.

[larryx]

wtf???duran was ****ing 50 and still went 12 with camacho..lol

[dondi330]

I can pick a gatekeeper type, that every good fighter in the weight divisions around him fought on their way up in an era, and say hey look at that awsome resume.

You do that and let me see the name. Im from the show me state.

[krispy kreme]

Good question. Chavez lost the big fights tho.

That's what I looked at too, but so did Camacho, when he faced guys like DLH & Trinidad. I don't know, I just say Camacho.

Yes ...just meant who he fought....Winning a fight can easily be challenged by us fans (but don't want to get into that)...Chavez with Whitaker and Meldrick Taylor Etc....Camacho with Rosario and Duran.....Some fans can say the other guys won too...Face it if you guys followed both of their careers....They both had some controversial wins (like I said dont want to get into that). Also a "resume" Does not necessarily mean who they beat....a resume shows your experience.

I definitely didn't follow either guys career, just watched what I could.

[dondi330]

That's what I looked at too, but so did Camacho, when he faced prime guys, like DLH & Trinidad. I don't know, I just say Camacho.

Just imagine if Chavez fought Trinidad around the same time Hoya fought Chavez....hmmm

[krispy kreme]

Just imagine if Chavez fought Trinidad around the same time Hoya fought Chavez....hmmm

Another ass whooping probably would have been in store for Chavez.

[DarchinyFAN]

You do that and let me see the name. Im from the show me state.

Look at someone like George Chuvalo

Competitors included
Muhammad Ali x2
Joe Frazier
George Foreman
Cleveland Williams
Jerry Quarry
Buster Mathis
Floyd Patterson
Zora Folley
Jimmy Ellis
Ernier Terrell

Now granted Chuvalo is better than your average gatekeeper, but if we are just saying Resume's are who you fought, you could say his is better than some of these all time greats that beat him.

Just for fun I picked just a random fighter off Chuvalo's opponents who had a number of fights, just so I could have someone less successful.

Willi Besmanoff fought the following

Bob Foster
Muhammad Ali
Zora Folley x2
Archie Moore x2
Willie Pestrano
Eddie Machen
Sonny Liston
George Chuvalo x3

Anyway I got bored but you get my point