Who benefits more from a Pac vs. Floyd match?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • badboypeenoy
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Feb 2008
    • 3203
    • 54
    • 44
    • 9,669

    #1

    Who benefits more from a Pac vs. Floyd match?

    The way I see it, this fight is all for Mayweather's benefit as far as status/prestige and respect is concerned because Pacquiao doesn't need to prove anything anymore; Pacquiao has already achieved respectability by being the best fighter to come out of Asia, climbing all the way from flyweight to welter, fighting the bests along the way to achieve that feat. It is Mayweather who needs a believable challenge to solidify his own claim to ATG status.

    Floyd is just waiting for that opportunity and a particular type of fighter that he thinks he'd look good beating, he certainly won't gamble his unbeaten streak against the elites of his own division like Margarito, Williams and even Cotto. He needs a winnable fight for which to get respect from mainstream fans, something that has eluded him because of his "cowardly" style. Pacquiao is smaller, as Pacquiao can still go comfortable down to 135 if he chooses to and Mayweather can't; gives an inch in height and a couple of inches in reach; has not had that much fight experience in the junior welter/welterweight divisions; has the name and the accomplishment that would be a perfect centerpiece to any dull resume; has legions of fans; and lastly can bring in the money.

    Americans have not had an ATG in the lower weights for quite a while now, I hope this is not another way for them to "decision win" their way into the record books by making a a dull fighter look great by winning over a smaller opponent. If Pacquiao wins or loses, it changes little to his already impressive resume, while Floyd winning gives history a reason to give respect to a cowardly boxer that doesn't deserve any IMO.

    5
    Floyd benefits more from this fight
    60.00%
    3
    Pacquiao benefits more from this fight
    40.00%
    2
  • MANGLER
    Sex Tape Flop Artist
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Feb 2008
    • 30142
    • 1,705
    • 2,355
    • 46,598

    #2
    Pac can elevate his legacy wit a win over PBF. All PBF gets outta this fight is $. Even if he stops Pac, he still won't be fully respected til he beats an elite WW.

    Comment

    • aether
      Banned
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Dec 2006
      • 3337
      • 93
      • 59
      • 3,672

      #3
      probably pac.. but pbf would earn a lot of respect. at least from me.

      Comment

      • MOREBASS
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Jul 2006
        • 1416
        • 58
        • 30
        • 7,933

        #4
        Boxing as a sport, and its fans !


        The ultimate contrast of styles, and a great plot to the fight.

        Comment

        • Caxcan
          Undisputed Champion
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Jul 2008
          • 2664
          • 273
          • 96
          • 23,228

          #5
          they'd both benefit alot from a win. dlh and hatton are considered major wins on mayweather's record. if pac were to defeat hatton, mayweather would need to face pac in order to claim he was the best p4p of this era. he already ducked out on the ww division, he cant afford to avoid pac.... or the $$$ that fight would provide.

          Comment

          • Silencers
            Undisputed Champion
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • May 2006
            • 21957
            • 505
            • 235
            • 32,983

            #6
            Boxing benefits from the fight but out of the two fighters I'd say Pacquiao stands to gain more from the fight than Mayweather.

            Comment

            • badboypeenoy
              Undisputed Champion
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Feb 2008
              • 3203
              • 54
              • 44
              • 9,669

              #7
              Originally posted by mangler
              Pac can elevate his legacy wit a win over PBF. All PBF gets outta this fight is $. Even if he stops Pac, he still won't be fully respected til he beats an elite WW.
              A condition to this fight happening is that Pacquiao gets through Hatton. Pacquiao does that and he already eclipsed PBF's best wins, Pacquiao retires by then, he's an ATG sho-in. The only reason I see Pac taking this fight is for the money, PBF definitely gets props for beating the other claimant to the P4P #1 throne, something he can't claim winning over a welterweight elite like Cotto.

              Comment

              • badboypeenoy
                Undisputed Champion
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Feb 2008
                • 3203
                • 54
                • 44
                • 9,669

                #8
                Originally posted by JaguarJames
                they'd both benefit alot from a win. dlh and hatton are considered major wins on mayweather's record. if pac were to defeat hatton, mayweather would need to face pac in order to claim he was the best p4p of this era. he already ducked out on the ww division, he cant afford to avoid pac.... or the $$$ that fight would provide.
                That ^ definitely looks like PBF needing this fight more than Pacquiao does, don't you think?

                Comment

                • Mike_Dee
                  mathematical whiz kid
                  Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
                  • May 2006
                  • 961
                  • 49
                  • 48
                  • 7,192

                  #9
                  it seems that Pac is in the same situtation as in the Oscar fight. Pac has nothing to lose and everything (more) to gain.

                  Floyd wins: he'll retire and will be hounded by the media and fans for not fighitng a real welterweight fighter. A "black eye" of his career.

                  Floyd loses: He loses the only reason why people pay any attention to him, his undefeated record. That "zero" is the only reason why Floyd is a draw, people will pay to potentially see him loce or knocked out. And that lose will be also a black eye in his career and also meaning that Pacquiao would be named "fighter of the decade" and not Floyd.

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  TOP