Who has the better resume in your opinion; Calzaghe or Tua

[Flawless.]

you wanna bring up amateur resume's now?

david tua - bronze medal at the olympics , bronze medals at the world championships

what medals did joe calzaghe win in the ams?

can't babysit a medal for 9 years in the amateurs i think.

Calzaghe fans are in retreat mode

[DiegoFuego]

Abdullaev and Pinto beat Cotto in the amateurs

[Left Hook Tua]

Calzaghe fans are in retreat mode

no 40-yr. olds in the ams.

****! tua fought felix savon. felix savon won 3-4 gold medals.

even in the ams tua fought better opposition.

[hammerhiem]

How many HW Champ's present or former has Tau beaten, not for any backing up of arguements, I just can't be arsed searching through Boxrec.

As for the discussion at hand Cal > Tua, the guy never won a belt in a **** era. Ok he lost to Lewis but when the best names on your resume are Rahamn and Ruiz, you should probably be quiet when discussions turn to the subject.

Lennox Lewis (prime) Lost immaterial
Chris Byrd (prime) Lost Immaterial
Hasim Rahman (prime) Rahman prime or otherwise was crap
John Ruiz (prime) Ruiz was not in his prime when Tua fought him, that would be why he was fighting for an international title
Oleg Maskaev (prime) It was his 11th fight, he was already Ko'd in one by Oliver McCall by that stage aswell...
Ike Ibeabuchi (prime) Lost Immaterial
Michael Moorer (slightly past his prime) Slightly? 5 years past prime you mean.
Fres Oquendo (undefeated) So was Jeff lacy
Darrol Wilson (undefeated) He finished with a record of 27-10...
David Izon never even fought for a title not even a alphabeti spagetti one.

Are you trying to sabotage Tau?

[Welter_Skelter]

Tua lost EVERY fight that mattered..

[ACHlLLES]

Calzaghe fans are in retreat mode

That is like your millionth account on boxingscene because you always get banned for your ******ed posts. I guess getting banned a million times doesn't get it through your small iq that no one here likes you. BPP doesn't, no one.

[TheGreatA]

How many HW Champ's present or former has Tau beaten, not for any backing up of arguements, I just can't be arsed searching through Boxrec.

Resume could mean the names you beat or the names you fought. If it's about the names they fought, you could make a case for Tua as he fought a lot of good fighters near their prime. Calzaghe has obviously achieved more in his career.

Maskaev was pretty much in his prime in 1997-1999, Ruiz was a better fighter at the time than he was later on in my opinion, Rahman, Izon and Wilson were decent fighters who were either coming off or went on to score some good wins.

I was exaggerating because the thread starter is known for his idiotic threads and rants. Left Hook Tua on the other hand is a good poster who isn't always to be taken that seriously.

[Left Hook Tua]

Resume could mean the names you beat or the names you fought. If it's about the names they fought, you could make a case for Tua as he fought a lot of good fighters near their prime. Calzaghe has obviously achieved more in his career.

Maskaev was pretty much in his prime in 1997-1999, Ruiz was a better fighter at the time than he was later on in my opinion, Rahman, Izon and Wilson were decent fighters who were either coming off or went on to score some good wins.

I was exaggerating because the thread starter is known for his idiotic threads and rants. Left Hook Tua on the other hand is a good poster who isn't always to be taken that seriously.

i take offense to that......



anyways......are you going to the lakers game tonight against new orleans?

i think kobe is gonna have a good game.

if so , i'll see you there. i can't believe you always get better seats at staples than me......

[-MAKAVELLI-]

i take offense to that......



anyways......are you going to the lakers game tonight against new orleans?

i think kobe is gonna have a good game.

if so , i'll see you there. i can't believe you always get better seats at staples than me......

where do you normally sit?

[WLAD_OWNS]

Calzaghe obviously has a better resume

Tua never won a world title