Which fighters of the last decade make it into the ATG list?

[dde91]

Marquez is not an ATG lol what a joke

As of right now, Not he isn't. But in after his career is done, he does have a chance. n i meant to put him in my borderline with winky, mosely, and the klit bros

[Ishy Aytan]

This list should be kept for the creme de la creme of our sport, no disrespect to Marquez, klitchsko's, Mosley's etc, but how can they be atg's when they never even were the p4p no1 best of their own era?

[dde91]

This list should be kept for the creme de la creme of our sport, no disrespect to Marquez, klitchsko's, Mosley's etc, but how can they be atg's when they never even were the p4p no1 best of their own era?

Then the only ATG of this era is Pac, Mayweather, Hopkins, and Jones because they were the only ones that were number 1 p4p in the rankings?

[Wales08]

Calzaghe
De La Hoya
Mayweather
Roy Jones Jr
Pacquiao
Lewis
Holyfield

[Ishy Aytan]

Then the only ATG of this era is Pac, Mayweather, Hopkins, and Jones because they were the only ones that were number 1 p4p in the rankings?

oohhh i see ur point, i'd put Morales and Barerra in as well.

Calzaghe? no way

[daggum]

why are people saying calzaghe? might as well say jermain taylor then since he has 2 wins over hopkins.

[hammerhiem]

ATG need special special fighters.

Lennox Lewis - Undisputed champ, beat all his major rivals.
PBF - Multiweight champ, P4P No1, beat genuine champs at 3 weights.
RJJ - Multiweight Champ, P4P No1, beat geuine champs at 2 weights and getting from MW to HW is a tremendous feat
Bhop - Still top 10 P4P at 43 awesome, gets in on the Pavlik distruction.

Not in but honourable mentions

Calzaghe, ODLH, Pacman (might get in by the end of the 00's), Morales, Barrera.

[Ishy Aytan]

ATG need special special fighters.

Lennox Lewis - Undisputed champ, beat all his major rivals.
PBF - Multiweight champ, P4P No1, beat genuine champs at 3 weights.
RJJ - Multiweight Champ, P4P No1, beat geuine champs at 2 weights and getting from MW to HW is a tremendous feat
Bhop - Still top 10 P4P at 43 awesome, gets in on the Pavlik distruction.

Not in but honourable mentions

Calzaghe, ODLH, Pacman (might get in by the end of the 00's), Morales, Barrera.

Its true, Calzaghe should'nt be in here. How can 2 fights make you an ATG, because i can gurantee last year no one would even mention him as an ATG.

[hammerhiem]

Its true, Calzaghe should'nt be in here. How can 2 fights make you an ATG, because i can gurantee last year no one would even mention him as an ATG.

I happen to think that 21 defences 7 against former/future champs, unifying 1 division, ring belts in two and retiring undefeated is worth a mention.

He's not ATG based on 2 things.

1. Frank Warren
2. A weak SMW division, or at least a SMW division short on good North Americans.

[_Hunter_]

Joe calzaghe of course