Haye vs. Valuev. Who would win?

[The_Visitation]

Haye by comprehensive UD. His chin isn't an issue, as Valuev would never hit it.

The only question mark is whether Haye can adapt his style, as he would need to. He would need to fight much more defensively rather than looking for a KO he will never get, but even doing that he should still take every round.

[Guest]

huH? Did you see the fight? The guy is awful... All three of them should beat him.

Valuev beat the **** out of Lyhaiovich and Ruiz and now he's chopped liver because of one bad fight. He also beat the **** out of Barrett and had a tough battle against Chagaev.
Don't judge a fighter by one bad performance.

[Flawless.]

I wouldnt say he had a bad fight. He fought the way he always does. Holyfield had taken a page out of Chageev's blueprint for defeating Valuev, and Holyfield nearly pulled it off.

Question is if Haye has the skills to do the same. I cannot see Haye knocking Valuev out TBH.

What you mean he nearly pull it off, what was your scorecard

[BattlingNelson]

What you mean he nearly pull it off, what was your scorecard

I had Holyfield 115-113. But that's irrelevant as the judges, who were ringside, saw it differently. Valuev got a majority decision so Holyfield was close.

[Flawless.]

I had Holyfield 115-113. But that's irrelevant as the judges, who were ringside, saw it differently. Valuev got a majority decision so Holyfield was close.

What are you trying to get at?? That it was ok the judges to score the fight to Valuev

[BattlingNelson]

What are you trying to get at?? That it was ok the judges to score the fight to Valuev

I am ok with the decision. It was a close (and boring) fight. A lot of close rounds that could go either way so I'm ok.

How did you score it?

[potatoes]

I think Haye would be better off fighting Nicolai Valuev than one of the Klit's.

But does he have what it takes to defeat the giant?

Does Holyfield have what it takes to defeat the giant? Apparently most of the people posting in this forum think so. Valuev obviously has no idea how to handle opponents who move.

[Flawless.]

I am ok with the decision. It was a close (and boring) fight. A lot of close rounds that could go either way so I'm ok.

How did you score it?

You are ok with this decision what a joke and bias poster you are


116-112 Holyfield

No way could this fight been scored for Valuev or even a draw

[BattlingNelson]

You are ok with this decision what a joke and bias poster you are


116-112 Holyfield

No way could this fight been scored for Valuev or even a draw

Please accept that others have different opinions than you do.

Here's what american Yahoo thinks: "Yahoo! Sports scored it 116-112 for Valuev, primarily on account of Holyfield’s remorseless reluctance to throw leather in the second half of the contest."

Did you watch via stream?

[Guest]

Does Holyfield have what it takes to defeat the giant? Apparently most of the people posting in this forum think so. Valuev obviously has no idea how to handle opponents who move.

He beat 49 guys. You're telling me none of them moved?