Who is more shot? Roy or Oscar?

[El Chicano]

Both were recently defeated by the top P4P fighters in the world. Once P4P fighters themselves, Roy and Oscar have diminished to a point that it's undeniable that they are now "shot". In your opinion, based on their last performances, who do u believe is more "shot"?

Roy Jones Jr.

or

Oscar De La Hoya

[S.G.]

based on their last performaces, Oscar

before that i probably would have said Jones though

[Chr0nic]

compared to how jones was a couple of years ago, jones, like people say, he did'nt slide down the hill, the man fell off that mother****er

[VERDUGO]

LOL at people who picked Oscar.
There was a poll like this before the Pacquiao fight on who among BHOP,ROY, and OSCAR is the most shot. Roy got the most vote and Oscar got the least.
Anyway, Oscar is only 35 and never been knocked out.
Roy is 40 and got KTFO COLD Twice.

[Golden Boy 360]

Roy.....did you see how calzaghe was taunting him hands all the way down and roy didnt throw any....i think weight is oscars problem

[sitai]

clearly roy...
he was a more exceptional fighter than oscar to begin with...
he has fallen further from his maximum potential

we still don't know whether oscar might have something left at 154..

[Trim0]

obviously, it's oscar
roy can still beat anybody besides calzaghe

[hishaam15]

Based on previous performances, Oscar...
But Roy seems much more shot because he was that good in his prime.