Who was Puerto Ricos best: Cotto or Trinidad?

[Bushbaby]

Go Cotto

I think Trinidad would have done better against Margarito because Trinidad was also a big welter weight,but at the same time im pretty sure that Mosley would have boxed circles around Trinidad.Trinidad was great going forward and throwing bombs and fighting fire with fire,but Cotto all around is much more rounded.Cotto will probably do greater things his time around.

[C.Y.]

this is easy.. Trinidad of course
miguel cotto isnt a bad fighter but he is definately overrated.. its also too early to compare their careers but imo tito has a big lead and i dont think cotto is going to catch up.. felix carried pr on his back and always fought the best opposition and never quit.. can't say the same for cotto.. we will find out alot about miguel's career this upcoming year so we'll see how it turns out

[The Scientist]

I have to go with trinidad, think cotto was a bit overrated.

what do you guys think?

Tito was PR's best, Cotto is not done yet. I believe he will become greater than Trinidad (even though Tito is more popular). Tito was a one trick pony that was very good at that one trick, Cotto is a versatile fighter that still has time for improvement.

Accomplishment wise Tito takes the trophy

Skill wise Cotto over Tito all day everyday.